Thursday, April 5, 2012

Calling Sri Aurobindo a terrorist

The Puducherry foreign regional registration office’s order to send back Peter Heehs, US historian and author of The Lives Of Sri Aurobindo, has created ripples within the UPA government. Rural development minister Jairam Ramesh shot a letter to home minister P Chidambaram on Wednesday to revoke the visa cancellation order, pointing out that the US author has been living in India for 40 years.
Categorically stating that he has no personal rapport with Heehs and had met the author only thrice, that too at public events, Ramesh hailed him for authoring one of the best biographies on Sri Aurobindo. He said Hees had also written seven other books on India during his stay here.
Government sources, however, said that the Puducherry Foreigner Regional Registration Officer’s decision to cancel the historian’s visa hinged on violation of norms. “Heehs’s visa had expired last year, but he was allowed to continue staying in India pending disposal of his representation,” an official said. “It is not as simple a case as it has been made out to be.” Heehs was told to leave India before April 15.
This is not the first time Ramesh has spoken against the visa rules laid down by the union home ministry. While touring China, Ramesh spoke in favour of easier Indian visa norms for the Chinese, setting off a controversy back home. It was earlier alleged that Heehs’s visa was cancelled at the behest of extremists who did not approve of his book on Sri Aurobindo.

RY Deshpande
May we know what was the occasion for the three meetings mentioned in the post? Were they history-connected, history in the strictest sense? If Mr Heehs is here in the Ashram for spiritual pursuits, how did the meetings promote those spiritual prospects? If there were other factors please let us know them.
I'm also aware that there are hundreds of posts and comments on the web-pages criticising the book on technical-professional grounds. Please peruse them before making any hurried judgement about this work. Thanks
GK Gokhale
Has Mr Jairam Ramesh read the book, The Lives of Sri Aurobindo, or is he simply going by the three 'chance' meetings with the author? It is not at all history, but is full of distortions calling Sri Aurobindo a Terrorist. Does he agree to that?
Surinder Sharma
Is this Jairam Ramesh extra constitutional add on who has inherent habit of political survival by going against the currents of rational pragmatic laws of the land. Illogical illegal tantrums of Jairam Ramesh have already cost nation very dearly he has no business to overshoot his assigned refrains & compulsively tread on forbidden terrains to lead Indian union home minister by nose during his tour  in foreign land.
P Chidambaram has taken best decision conforming to national interests as long years of stay in India by controversial USA historian Heehs do not automatically give him immunity from expulsion for unlawful activities.  As on the contrary British were shown the door for distorting  history of India despite centuries of stay.
Dr. D.S. Rao
Peter Heehs is an anti-India person and must be watched. Jairam Ramesh it is no secret has links in the USA. P Chidambaram is correct in his decision. Ramesh can not and must not be trusted in sensitive Indian affairs.
Guest
PC getting all decisions wrong. God help us, whatever happened to the moderate, opinion hearing Indian?!
It was earlier alleged that Heehs’s visa was cancelled at the behest of extremists who did not approve of his book on Sri Aurobindo. And that is the correct story indeed!

Talk by Shraddhalu at Nairobi Centre of Sri Aurobindo Society part ...
07 March 2012, Sri Aurobindo Bhavan, Nairobi Centre of Sri Aurobindo Society

Gautam Chikermane ‏ @gchikermane Excellent programme on NDTV that exposes the fundamentalist: Historian faces expulsion: Are we an intolerant democracy? 12:28 PM - 4 Apr 12


from: Chris Duindam chris.duindam@live.nl date: 4 April 2012 15:48 subject: RE [sbicitizen] Re: Nature and we can make life sustainable Messages in this topic (6) Dear All
I have learned to live in this world by study and hard work. There have always been rich and poor and that will never go. These kind of stories will always be there. What important is to follow a yoga practice. As richness is lost at death and yoga practice is not. So look at what happened in the world without being attached to it. And be open to the Divine Reality following Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. Greetings, Chris
View My Stats Wednesday 4th April 2012 – 305 Page Loads

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Chikermane tears ‏

Tweets Gautam Chikermane ‏ @gchikermane Real issue: India - country of Gita, Vedas, Upanishadas - cannot tolerate truth or alternative points of view. Heehs is latest victim. 12:19 PM - 4 Apr 12 via web · Only security issue around Peter Heehs: religious fundamentalists organised a dharna, assaulted an Ashram Trustee and turned blame on Heehs. 12:17 PM - 4 Apr 12 via web · Religious fundamentalists all set to win: Chidambaram won’t allow US historian Peter Heehs to stay in India 12:15 PM - 4 Apr 12 via web ·
Zoom Indian Media ‏ @ZoomIndianMedia IE censors that "Peter Heehs" was ex-CABBIE, says SCHOLAR? Cric journo Guha certifies? PC interferes? http://is.gd/qoDNaJ HT @rupasubramanya 11:09 AM - 4 Apr 12 via TweetDeck - @gchikermane @monikahalan Can assertions by dubious make ex-CABBIE "Peter Heehs" a HISTORIAN/SCHOLAR? #scurrilous #propaganda

1.    Peter Heehs, a US national who is a self-styled "scholar" and writer, published a book called The Lives of Sri Aurobindo, purporting to be a biography of Sri Aurobindo. By his own admission, Peter Heehs has no formal educational qualifications in any discipline, is a school dropout and was formerly a taxi driver in the USA. Heehs is no historian of any kind and came to India as an uneducated and unemployed youth seeking rehabilitation.
2.      In his offensive book titled The Lives of Sri Aurobindo Heehs has made elaborate and devious attempts to malign and defame the mahayogi, spiritual giant and freedom fighter Sri Aurobindo whose life-size statue stands in the parliament and who is a hero of India's freedom struggle at par with giants such as Mahatma Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru and Sardar Patel.
3. Heehs is a habitual and serial impersonator regularly indulging in academic fraudulence in order to hide his lack of credentials, and has declared to various publishers including Columbia Press in the USA that he is "one of the founders of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram Archives". This is patently false. With other publishers, he has on other occasions declared himself as "curator", "director" and "director of historical research" of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram Archives. All of these are false representations and amount to impersonation and academic fraudulence. […]
For the last twenty years and more, Peter Heehs has been conducting a personal business of authoring books and articles and receiving payments from their sales, which has nothing to do with the purpose for which he was granted his visa and is in flagrant violation of his visa conditions... Peter Heehs is not an income tax assessee in India and has evaded tax payments in India for all the income received both from within India and from abroad.

Graham Harman on Atheism Graham Harman recently posted about the tendency of atheist intellectuals to dismiss anyone with a theistic worldview:
“Disbelief in God was cutting-edge in the 1600′s and is still cutting edge at age 15. I’m not saying you should believe in God after those two landmarks; I’ll leave that up to you. I’m just saying, it seems a bit absurd to use the question of someone’s belief or disbelief in God as one of the chef pillars of your judgment about that person’s intellectual caliber.”
RECENT COMMENTS on Purpose in Living Systems
Matthew David Segall says: April 3, 2012 at 4:53 pm He consistently collapses a Whiteheadian reading of formal and final causes into the ID/Creationist reading. Its just sloppy. To give him the benefit of the doubt, I might be more allergic even to a panentheistic conception of the relation of God and the World if I lived in Texas surrounded by fundamentalists. But alas, I live in San Francisco surrounded by psychedelic shamans and new age Buddhists. Once in a while I run into an Episcopalian. I would really like to hear from the other SR/OOO thinkers on this issue. I can’t imagine Tim Morton, Graham Harman, or Iain Hamilton Grant being very sympathetic to his argument…

We are of course talking about Brendan Purcell's From Big Bang to Big Mystery: Human Origins in the Light of Creation and Evolution, which, like our One Cosmos, attempts to pack the whole existentialida -- the whole cosmic drama -- into a combo-plate in the head of about 300 pages. It is the only other recent book of which I am aware that synthesizes everything from physics to anthropology to paleontology to biology to history to mysticism to theology to mind parasites into one convenient narrative -- but in a non-stupid manner, since anyone can do it the other way…
At the same time, we had some mutually exclusive influences, including some who are quite central to my approach, thus accounting for differences in sensibility and emphasis. For example, I don't expect that too many other people -- well, none actually -- will share my enthusiasm for W.R. Bion, Allan Schore, Robert Rosen, Valentin Tomberg, James Joyce, and Fritjhof Schuon, especially in combination. 

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Samanta on Swarnalata

from: Prithwin Mukherjee prithwin.mukherjee@gmail.com to: "Tusar N. Mohapatra" tusarnmohapatra@gmail.com date: 3 April 2012 19:20 subject: I REFUTE
SWARNALATA, INSANE?
From Terrorism in Bengal, Ed. Amiya K. Samanta, Government of West Bengal, Calcutta, 1995, Vol. V: W. Sealy's "Connections with the Revolutionary Organization in Bihar and Orissa (1906-1916)" 
p.18: In 1907, Barin rented Sil's (or Seal's) Lodge from its owner Devendra Nath Sil, the full address given on p.16 : "Raidhi, P.O. Rohini, via Baidyanath, Deoghar". This was Barin's first bomb factory (pp.16-17) 
p20: The police was informed that  "machinery used by the conspirators at Sil's Lodge, might be found at Raidih, buried under the ground" (§24). 
p20 : On 15 February 1908, the compound of the house at Raidih, "in which Arabinda's (§22) mother [Swarnalata]  had lived, was dug up (...) A vice, portion of a drilling machine, a wrench, 4 drills, and bolts and nuts were recovered, buried deep in the ground. Saran Lata [Swarnalata]  used to rush out with a sword whenever anyone approached the Raidih house."(§25).
It was obvious that Swarnalata made full use of her so called "insanity", judging from the way she instructed her servants to bury such articles, as revealed by this Report.  

Integral Yoga | Integral Library
In this collection of 156 extracts from letters to disciples, Sri Aurobindo explains the central principles and practices of his Integral Yoga. “There can be no firm ...

Issues facing the Auroville Council are mentioned briefly in an interview with Cauvery. A ...
From the book "By the way", 1st edition, published 18th October, 1997, page 49 Richard came into the office one day and said: "Dada, I've read Sports Spirit and I have a question." "What is it?" He had written down the question. Dada read his question and said: Why haven't I participated in the Ashram [...] Read more of this post - Govind | April 3, 2012 at 3:08 pm URL: http://wp.me/p9L4p-2P

Anonymous has left a comment on your post "Odia trustee": >>...we demand induction of a person of Odia origin as a trustee of Sri Aurobindo Ashram, Puducherry...>>
What other quotas would you like the SAAT to reserve for its trustees? STs? SCs? OBCs? North Indians? South Indians? Reddys? Ranades? Pandeys? Mohapatras????
If we go about it this way, the SAAT will have 2000 trustees and 5 non-trustees (the existing ones!). It is surprising that all these brilliant "devotees" come up with the most brilliant suggestions that even the Mother in Her eternal wisdom didn't think about. And talking about an Odia Trustee for the SAAT, it is absolutely not true that an Oriya cannot become a Trustee. In fact, Manoj Das, an eminent Odia, was a Trustee of the Ashram. If he chose to resign for his personal reasons the SAAT cannot be blamed for the lack of "representation" of Odias in the SAAT. Vijay Posted by Anonymous to Savitri Era at 8:46 PM, April 03, 2012

A group of Indian historians is objecting to the treatment of the American scholar Peter Heehs, who is under growing pressure from Hindu conservatives to leave the country,reports the Hindustan Times. Mr. Heehs has written extensively on modern Indian history and religion, but some Hindu fundamentalists have objected to his book about Sri Aurobindo, a freedom fighter and spiritual leader who died in 1950. They say the book, which was published by Columbia University Press in 2008, misrepresents the historical figure’s relationship with a female collaborator.
Court filings have prevented the book’s distribution in India, and now reportedly Mr. Heehs may have his visa revoked. Indian academics sent a letter last month to the prime minister and home minister to raise concerns about the situation. A similar controversy erupted last year, when the The Collected Essays of A.K. Ramanujan was criticized for offending Hindu sensibilities. This entry was posted in India. Bookmark the permalink.

Ensure that Sri Aurobindo is not converted into a religious figure

Tweets Nilanjana Roy ‏ @nilanjanaroy The Peter Heehs case shows how easy it is to use "blasphemous" as an excuse to persecute an author: http://bit.ly/HLbz5F Ram Guha on the long tradition of cross-cultural scholarship that includes Peter Heehs: http://bit.ly/Hj3Ibs Chidambaram says he'll take a decision on Heehs' visa by today 12:11 PM - 3 Apr 12 via TweetDeck · Details - Anja Kovacs ‏ @anjakovacs RT @nilanjanaroy
ramesh sharma ‏ @rameshfilms Must read @nehathirani: Ram Guha on the visa extension of historian Peter Heehs & contribution of foreigners in India
Neha Thirani ‏ @nehathirani Ram Guha on the visa extension of historian Peter Heehs & the considerable contribution of foreigners living in India
Gautam Chikermane ‏ @gchikermane Amazing sense of perspective on the Peter Heehs affair by Ramachandra Guha: In Hume's footsteps
naresh fernandes ‏ @tajmahalfoxtrot Ram Guha explains why historian Peter Heehs must be allowed to stay in India. 

Vishnupada has left a comment on your post "Inmate of an Ashram can’t claim unbridled freedom": Banning a book is a fashion only. It can never solve the basic problem. It can not root out the controversy. total banning of a book only bring out blasphemy and black marketing in total.
the readers should compel the author to revise the book and compel the publishers to publish only the revised book in future from where ever the book may be published. Posted by Vishnupada to Savitri Era at 4:21 PM, April 03, 2012

vishnupada wrote... All the clever writers and publishers from Europe and America make their books controversial only and to make money. It is their mania. This mania goes to the top when the matter or content does not... Continue >>

Letter to Home Minister of India, Honorable Sri Chidambaram – Arindam Das from Posthuman Destinies by debbanerji APRIL 3, 2012 the permalink To Thiru P. Chidambaram Hon’ble Minister of Home Affairs Subject: Renewal of Peter Heeh’s visa Respected Hon’ble Minister,
Your decision to review the decision taken by the FRO Puducherry not to renew Peter Heeh’s visa comes as a ray of hope for many of us who have followed this controversy for some time now. I am a devotee of Sri Aurobindo and grew up in the ashram. I have read Heeh’s book “The Lives of Sri Aurobindo” and have liked it immensely. It has increased my knowledge and understanding of Sri Aurobindo and his yoga. This book is a wonderful proponent of meticulous research and intellectual honesty that will go a long way in establishing a tradition of holistic understanding of Sri Aurobindo as spiritual seeker, a revolutionary leader, a poet and a visionary. To expel Heehs from this country would be nothing short of persecution.
The allegation that Heehs has deliberately tried to portray Sri Aurobindo in poor light is completely unfounded. Many of us have maintained that there is a false propaganda at play to purposely malign the book and the writer for motives that are best known to the detractors.
Please consider the following:
1. The people who have raised their voice against the book are only a small minority within the ashram. It is widely believed that this minority has been using the book and the writer as a pretext to get at the ashram Trust board with whom they have a difference of opinion.
2. Most of the people who have been protesting against the book have not even read the book. It may be noted that the book is not even readily available in India due to the pending court case in Orissa. It is therefore anyone’s guess that this protest has been built on falsehood and vested interests where people are simply being used as pawns.
3. It is a well-known fact that the agitation against the book and the writer is being fed by external elements from outside Puducherry. Bus loads of people were brought in from other states to participate in a dharna. The number of participants did not exceed 250 out of which only a handful – about 10-15 – belonged to the ashram. The ashram has a population of close to 2000 inmates.
4. The wider intellectual/academic community has come out in support of the book.
5. A number of devotees both inside and outside the country who have read the book have liked it and have gone on record to say that it has helped them in their understanding of Sri Aurobindo and his yoga.
6. Several debates have already taken place in many internet forums where the book has been discussed threadbare. At no point of time the detractors have been able to present any cogent argument to support their case. All that they have done all along is that they have quoted selective extracts to drive home their points. It may be noted that this group already stands discredited within the ashram and among the larger body of devotees across the country and the world. Most organizations connected to the ashram such as Auroville, the ashram school’s alumni fraternity and independent centers across the world have not endorsed their view.
7. It is fairly clear now from the proceedings in the court case that the gazette notification in the state of Orissa was taken out in undue haste without taking into consideration all the facts of the case.
8. Heehs is an established scholar and a historian. He has lived in the ashram and India for over 40 years and has contributed immensely to the digitization and organizing of innumerable original manuscripts of Sri Aurobindo. He has several books to his credit and has written many articles in various international journals. Expelling him from the country on account of a very small and vocal group of minority would not only be seen as an unusually harsh step but also portray India as an intolerant society.
9. As disciples of Sri Aurobindo we grew up with the ethos that the teachings of Sri Aurobindo do not constitute a religion. There is also a Supreme Court judgement to this effect that says that Sri Aurobindo’s teachings cannot be considered as a religion. It is therefore the duty of all of us, the devotees and the Indian state, to ensure that Sri Aurobindo is not converted into a religious figure and that nobody is allowed to take recourse to arguments of hurt religious feelings. This would be seen as the real betrayal of Sri Aurobindo.
10. We must respect freedom of thought, approach and expression. It will be wrong to say that there can be only one way to look at Sri Aurobindo. As a free-thinking individual I should be allowed to follow my own likes and judgement and decide for myself which approach is the best for me. Heehs has written a book which is a result of painstaking research, an urge to bring forth the many facets of Sri Aurobindo’ life and a silent respect for Sri Aurobindo as a person. This is his approach. He has not broken any law of the land. He is also not telling us that this is the only approach. Those who do not like this approach can always write another book or read another book.
I am an ordinary citizen of this country. It is with a great deal of hope that I write this letter to you with a full belief that you will allow Peter Heehs to stay back in India and continue with his sadhana. This would go a long way in portraying this great country as a civil and tolerant society which has learnt to live with many views. Sincerely, Arindam Das Puducherry

After a furore over his controversial biography on spiritual leader and nationalist Sri Aurobindo, well-known American historian Peter Heehs faces the prospect of being asked to leave India. Even as the government mulls the extension of his visa, we debate if this incident is yet another example of a serious threat to the freedom of speech and expression in the country. « NDTV Indian National Broadcast: Peter Heehs an Important Test Case for Democracy in India NDTV LINK to All India Broadcast on Peter Heehs as the Home Minister’s mules a decision in the case of his expulsion from India. The interview devotes plenty of time to framing the debate as an important test case for democracy in India.  Those knowing ones who warned that a reactionary response to the book and a movement to evict the author from the Ashram and India would only elevate his status to that of Salman Rushdie, M.F. Husain and others who have had their freedom compromised by fundamentalist incitement have been proven only too correct in this national television broadcast. permalink
SCIY first took issue with the Hindu extremist world view of Kittu Ready in 2006, in response to an article entitled the Kargil Crisis in which he declared Pakistan must come under India’s military control in order for India to fulfill her spiritual mission and destiny. His reasoning was as distorted in that instance as it is in this television interview. Link to the NDTV National Broadcast Historian faces expulsion: Are we an intolerant democracy?

Monday, April 2, 2012

Heehs caught between the visa and the book

Tweets (Updated 12:40 PM): Gautam Chikermane ‏ @gchikermane Religious fundamentalists win again, but Chidambaram review today. Chidambaram may change that decision today Zoom Indian Media ‏ @ZoomIndianMedia - @nationalizer Was not Peter Heehs a New York cabbie? Did he turn historian? He studied History? Malini Parthasarathy ‏ @MaliniP Am unhappy with the move to expel Peter Heehs who has written a splendid biography of Sri Aurobindo. What's happened to our famed tolerance? Ashok ‏ @nationalizer What is about Historian Peter Heehs latest book on Aurobindo? What did he write? who r offended? Malini Parthasarathy ‏ @MaliniP Heeh's meticulously researched narration of Aurobindo's evolution shows him transcending his human frailties and thereby truly inspiring. utpal chattopadhyay ‏ @uc59 - @MaliniP From my imperfect understanding of the freedom movement & Aurobindo's role in it, he was a TOTAL cop-out IMHO. A lot of mumbo jumbo 2 Malini Parthasarathy ‏ @MaliniP - @uc59 Yes, but he was definitely a spiritual seeker and an inspiration for many others. Heehs' biography is respectful while being honest 9:17 PM - 1 Apr 12 utpal chattopadhyay ‏ @uc59 - @MaliniP of course I do not support revoking of this visa if that is based on what he wrote in his book. Prabhu Rajadurai ‏ @prabhuadvocate - @MaliniP Famed tolerance? Where do you live? Ask James Laine, Salman Rushdie, MF Hussain, Dan Brown about our tolerance Vidya Bhushan Rawat ‏ @freetohumanity - @sagarikaghose This govt is on its way out now and becoming more communalised and rigid ignoring people's voice. Shameful.

Let Heehs stay, scholars urge PM - Debjani Dutta Express News Service Last Updated : 02 Apr 2012 07:43:55 AM IST PUDUCHERRY:
Taking up the case of American historian Peter Heehs, whose controversial book ‘Lives of Aurobindo’ has led to an issue with his visa, around 30 renowned historians and scholars, including Union Minister for Rural Development Jairam Ramesh, have written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Union Home Minister P Chidambaram .
“It (the book) is among the finest-ever written of a major Indian Nationalist and spiritualist. Factional disagreements in Heehs’ home town should not receive the implicit support of the Indian state, which would happen if the Home ministry were to deny him a visa allowing him to continue in India. It would be greatly to the detriment of our country to be seen as having driven out an internationally recognised scholar who is committed to writing biography and history of the highest calibre. We urge you to grant Heehs his visa at the earliest, so that he is not forced to leave our shores by April 15,” the letter said. It is to be seen what decision is taken by the Home Minister on Monday.

Historian tries to buy peace, offers trade-off - Debjani Dutta Express News Service Last Updated : 02 Apr 2012 08:56:30 AM IST PUDUCHERRY:
Facing possible expulsion from the country he has been living in for decades after his controversial book Lives of Sri Aurobindo published in the US in 2008 sparked unease among followers of the spiritual leader, American historian Peter Heehs, on Sunday said he was prepared for a revised Indian version of his book to be published by Penguin India. The visa of Heehs, a resident of the ashram here, is set to expire in the second week of April. Union Home Minister P Chidambaram is set to decide on Monday whether or not to extend it.
Regretting the controversy, Heehs said both he and the publishers were prepared to strike out any “questionable” passages. “Got permission for publishing the modified version for use of devotees,” Heehs told Express. “I had given two proposals—one to recompose certain passages which had become controversial and the other to allow yet another publication for the devotees—as a few changes may not satisfy those opposed to the book. Though there would be a financial loss for the publishers as they would have to do the composition again, they were willing to do it,” said Heehs.
To publish the book, however, clearance is required from the Orissa High Court, which had banned its publication in 2008. The court had then issued a temporary injunction stating that until disposal of the appeal against the order, the book could be printed by obtaining a ‘No Objecti­on certificate’ from the Ministry of Home Affairs.

Khurshid Alam engages Jitendra Sharma in an interview with his concept of Man in Aurobindo's poetry on his recently released title, Concept of Man in Sri Aurobindo's Poetry. CLRI Que 2: Sri Aurobindo was a philosopher at heart. What is his contribution to Indian philosophy?
Ans: Most of the philosophers have always created a gulf between this world and beyond, but Sri Aurobindo creates the perfect synthesis of spirituality and the world. His theories of evolution, consciousness and matter place him at the forefront of Indian philosophers. He formulated a scientific and spiritual vision of evolution. He foresees a complete transformation of Man and the world. He believes that a new spiritualised race of humanity is about to come. His unusual life experiences convinced him of such future possibilities. He traced Man’s evolution through anthropology, sociology, politics, psychology, culture and religion in over 37 newly-published, huge volumes of writings.

Aurobindo Society ‏ @Aurobindo10 Savitri Era Devotees: 'Concept of Man in Sri Aurobindo's Poetry’: An In... savitrieradevotees - Jitendra Sharma ‏ @aurofrance Savitri Era Devotees: 'Concept of Man in Sri Aurobindo's Poetry': An In... 
Mihir Jha ‏ @MihirKumarJha A Living Paradox! Founder, Reader's Quotient. These days i m living here me.lt/3MUUk India readersquotient.com Those interested to read Karmyogin can download the pdf version here from the official site of Sri Aurobindo Ashram. The unique Spiritual, Philosophical and rational style in which the Legendary Sri Aurobindo used 2 deal with every topic. Sri Aurobindo Remarks on the guy (Max Muller) who studied Upanishadas whole life & translated for an Agenda: intyoga.online.fr

Sri Aurobindo showed how to perceive politics from the standpoint of spirituality

No legal cover for journalists refusing to divulge source Times of India – Manoj Mitta, TNN Apr 2, 2012, 05.44AM IST
In another stirring instance from the colonial era, Bipin Chandra Pal, who ran a daily called Bande Mataram, refused to confirm if Sri Aurobindo was the author of an anonymous article for which the latter was being tried for sedition. While Aurobindo was acquitted in 1907, Pal himself was sent to jail for six months for refusing to depose against him. The sacrifices made by Pal and Kavyabirsharad appear to have been in vain as independent India has not so far redressed the statutory lacuna that had landed them in jail during the colonial period…
Kaliprasanna Kavyabisharad, editor of Bengali publication Hitabadi, refused to name the author of a poem published in his paper. He was jailed for nine months Bipin Chandra Pal, who ran a daily called Bande Mataram, refused to confirm whether Sri Aurobindo was author of an anonymous article. Pal was jailed for six months… The rationale of the privilege otherwise recognized around the world is that journalists will be unable to play the role of a watchdog unless they can guarantee confidentiality to their sources. It is a departure from the general rule that everybody has a legal obligation to give evidence.  

There is in Sri Aurobindo a revolutionary, a poet, a philosopher, a visionary of evolution. He is not only the explorer of consciousness, but the builder of a new world. For evolution is not over: “Man is a transitional being,” he wrote at the beginning of the century. This now classic introduction to Sri Aurobindo (in a new edition and translation) not only tells us the story of his life, in itself a remarkable adventure; Satprem also takes us along in a methodical exploration of Sri Aurobindo’s “integral yoga,” showing how it leads to a “divine rehabilitation of Matter” and gives our painful evolution its meaning and hope.
“We have denied the Divinity in Matter to confine it in our holy places, and now Matter is taking its revenge — we called it crude, and crude it is. As long as we accept this Imbalance, there is no hope for the earth: we will swing from one pole to the other — both equally false — from material enjoyment to spiritual austerity, without ever finding our plenitude. We need both the vigor of Matter and the fresh waters of the Spirit…. Now the time may have come at last to unveil the Mysteries and to recover the complete truth of the two poles within a third position, which is neither that of the materialists nor that of the spiritualists.” Satprem

Khurshid Alam engages Jitendra Sharma in an interview with his concept of Man in Aurobindo's poetry on his recently released title, Concept of Man in Sri Aurobindo's Poetry. CLRI Que 1: Hi Jitendra, can you share the reason why you selected Sri Aurobindo Ghose’s works as your research topic while there are so many Indian writers in English? Particularly now there are a good number of Man Booker Prize winners also.
Ans: Sri Aurobindo, a great politician, philosopher, freedom-fighter, mystic, literary critic and Yogi, considered himself primarily a poet. He had an integral vision of life and spirituality. Sri Aurobindo’s poetry has already carved a niche for itself. His vast poetry, encompassing many forms and moods, expresses an enormous variety of emotions. All this provided me with a wide creative space for research…
In the psyche of humanity, Superman has always been an archetype. Around 1900, the notion of the superman became common in European philosophy. Many philosophers along with Friedrich Nietzsche tried to put forth theories and suggestions to alleviate human misery and improve the human condition. But it is extremely difficult to transform matter, the earth and Man.
Sri Aurobindo, based on a great and perfect philosophy, advocated an ideal world of social equality, fraternity and freedom. He showed how to perceive politics from the standpoint of spirituality. After clearing the incompleteness of Marx’s philosophy, he presented his integral philosophy in which the elements of the east and the west, past and future, science and religion, heart and mind, which seem contradictory to us, are presented in a beautifully synthesised image. Sri Aurobindo has a vision of the possibility of a divine life for man upon the earth. Sri Aurobindo emphasises the complementarities rather than the oppositions of Eastern and Western philosophies. He believes that all humans are of the same divine origin.

Criticism by Bhaskar Roy Barman - Contemporary Literary Review ... SUNDAY, APRIL 1, 2012 Savitri and Satyavan by Bhaskar Roy Barman
I shall discuss in this paper Sri Aurobindo’s epic poem, Savitri, based upon the Savitri-Satyavan legend in the Mahabharata, one of the two epics that India glories in, the other epic being the Ramayana. Many important and distinguished writers have written in English and in their native languages no mean number of stories, novels and poems, drawing upon a myriad of the legends in the Mahabharata and the Ramayana…
As I have hinted at, Aurobinda Ghosh (universally known as Sri Aurobindo), considered one of the greatest minds of the twentieth century, presented the literary world with the epic poem Savitri developed on the marrow of the Savitri-and-Satyavan episode…
The central myth in Aurobindo’s poetry, the myth of freedom, based, as it is, upon the dialectical struggle between the worlds of appearance and reality, matter and spirit, evil and good, and death and divine life, presses home the evolutionary value of human life and points up, as well, the quest of the soul for the state of being to be realized through an intuitive process of self-discovery and awareness of the infinite. It aims to ascend from the inconsistent state to the wakeful state through spiritual journey up the stairs of the world, the manifold planes of existence, the states of becoming, thus to experience, while ascending the stairs of the world, complete identity with substantive reality and the totality of being through inward expansion and synthesis. This Indian and romantic view of the soul’s ability to experience infinitude and to attain liberty from the deterministic order of lower nature inaugurates the core of Savitri. In fact Sri Aurobindo’s imagination foreglimpses and conjures up the idea of earth being a humankind’s ideal home, where one’s soul, by eschewing its egotistical selfhood in order to completely surrender itself to, and, by merging through common humanity with, universal consciousness, experiences joy and fulfilment.
Hence, Sri Aurobindo’s Savitri is often described as quintessentially an epic for the modern man, as it epitomizes his primary concerns and his existential angst. By ‘modern man’ is universally meant humanity which has reached a stage where he has achieved the highest and best consciousness; but he has not found himself rid of the age-old problems of death, suffering, inadequacy and ignorance. The inadequacy and the ignorance of man manifest themselves in the display of inequality, corruption, terrorism which brings about their suffering. Born out of Sri Aurobindo’s concern for humankind and its future, Savitri portrays the precise nature of the crisis humankind has come to grips with and suggests a way to tackle it. It is often said of Savitri with immunity that it deals with such a vast and grand theme –the revelation of the ranges of consciousness - as no other epic before has ever attempted.

Sri Aurobindo Devotees Prayer Centre: Pushpanjali and prayers to Sri Annai, Sasibalika Vidya Mandir, Azad Road, 9.30 a.m.; Sri Annai Meditation Centre, W 7C, Kovaipudur, 4 p.m.

Sunday, April 1, 2012

Auroville's politicians who manipulate and bully

The new hall houses two models of Matrimandir, one being the original rosewood model that was presented to The Mother. It features the layout for the whole gardens oval as originally proposed. The second a 3- D cut-away model of the Matrimandir building, allowing visitors to see how the Chamber is suspended in the upper hemisphere of the globe and its overall appearance with the twelve petals. The walls of the new hall are hung with eight large panels showing many more details of the construction and the significance the Mother has given to Matrimandir and its gardens. Quiet and unpretentious, the exhibition conveys to the visitor a sense of the depth and the beauty that lie at the center of the town. For booking for visits to the Inner Chamber: You may now phone between 10 am and 11:30 am to 0413 – 2622204.

Auroville Today > Current issue March 2012 
In the published conversations of The Mother on Auroville, the high expectations She had of the Aurovilians stand out. “Auroville voudrait être le berceau du surhomme” She wrote, ‘Auroville wants to be the cradle of the overman.’ Georges Van Vrekhem, the author of numerous books on Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, gives his views on this.
In the article ‘Patterns and predictability’ Alan reflects on why Auroville’s society is so very ordinary at present. “Like anywhere else in the world, we have our politicians who manipulate and bully to get their way; we have those who enrich themselves at the community’s expense; we have a thriving bureaucracy; we have our permanently disaffected ones who seem to draw energy only from protest; we have our freeloaders; and we have those who are intent only on cultivating their own gardens or businesses,” he writes. Why? ...
Auroville International held its yearly meeting this time in Auroville, and AVI members had a close interaction with many Auroville working groups. From such exchanges, one important role of AVI members became increasingly clear, writes Martin Littlewood. “Their goodwill, commitment and passion for the experiment of Auroville is obvious, but their level of detachment from daily preoccupations seems to bring another perspective to the work, and sometimes helps to unblock situations which have for many years been unmoving.” …
The third publication featured is ‘The Tale of my Exile’, a book written by Sri Aurobindo’s younger brother Barindra Ghose, popularly known as Barin, who was convicted in the Alipore Bomb Case and sentenced to death. On appeal, this was commuted to transportation for life to the Andaman Cellular Jail. Sachidananda Mohanty’s excellent introduction provides a brief overview of Barin’s life before and after the Andamans. More importantly, it clarifies the relationship between the two brothers and shows how, even if their later life trajectories differed, both shared an intensity of spiritual search and an undying opposition to any form of human oppression. The pdf.files of this issue can be downloaded here.

EXHIBITIONS Cyclone Inversions Large scale camera obscura photographic artifacts by Goetz Rogge and Future School students
Tuesday March 27 – Tuesday April 3 Parables of Dawn Digital paintings by Juergen P.
Friday April 6 to Saturday April 28 Meditations on Savitri – Book One – The Book of Beginnings Paintings by Huta – in the Picture Gallery-
FILMS Mondays 6:30 pm
April 2 : Sri Aurobindo – Glimpses of His Life Script and commentary by Manoj Das. A film from the Sri Aurobindo Society. Duration: 20 min
April 9 : Meditations on Savitri  Book 6  - The Book of Fate A film by Manohar of Huta’s paintings, illustrating passages from Savitri read by The Mother and accompanied by her own organ music. Duration: 40 min
April 16 : Adam Kadmon & The Evolution  Video of a talk by Georges Van Vrekhem Duration: 73min
April 23 :  The Mother -  Glimpses of Her Life  Duration: 18 min, and “Four Aspects of the Mother” Duration: 28 min
April 30: “Experiences with the Mother, Part 1” – Video of a talk by Narad (Richard Eggenberger) Duration: 42 min 
REGULAR  ACTIVITIES Sundays 10.30–12 noon: Savitri Study Circle
Mondays 3-4pm: Cultivating Concentration, in the light of Sri Aurobindo’s Yoga, led by Dr. Jai Singh 5-6pm: On The Mother, led by Dr. Ananda Reddy
Tuesdays 3-4pm: Cultivating Concentration, in the light of Sri Aurobindo’s Yoga, led by Dr. Jai Singh 4–5 pm: L’Agenda de Mère – listening to recordings with Gangalakshmi 5-6 pm: Savitri study in Tamil, led by Sudarshan 5.45 – 7.15 pm: OM Choir (details below)
Wednesdays 4.15-5.15 pm: ‘Mudra-Chi’ led by Anandi F. 5.30-6.30 pm: Reading The Life Divine, led by Shraddhavan
Thursdays 4-5 pm: The English of Savitri, led by Shraddhavan
Fridays 3-4pm: Cultivating Concentration, in the light of Sri Aurobindo’s Yoga, led by Dr. Jai Singh

TN Chaturvedi added his voice of support

@mihirssharma Behind Heehs's visa non extension are religious fundamentalists making great noise, lobbying. Heehs is a soft target. @mihirssharma Yes, but can't allow intellectuals to be thrown out of India. Good piece on visa circus

PC orders review into historian's visa row - Hindustan Times - Gautam Chikermane, Hindustan Times New Delhi: March 31, 2012
Home minister P Chidambaram on Saturday asked for a review of an order denying American historian Peter Heehs a visa extension. "This was noticed by me this morning," Chidambaram told reporters, referring to the HT report on how Heehs, an inmate of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram, was being denied visa extension. Heehs, who has been living in India for the past 41 years, was abruptly told by the foreigners' registration office (FRO) in Puducherry that his visa will not be extended anymore. The ostensible reason being his ninth book, The Lives of Sri Aurobindo.
For years, religious fundamentalists have been harassing Heehs over his non-hagiographic and more academic treatment of Sri Aurobindo's well-received biography. "I understand that the FRO has passed the order," Chidambaram said. "I have asked for a review. I am told that the file will be submitted to me on Monday, I will take a decision then." The FRO, who signs as Aruna, could not be contacted. Repeated calls and SMSes to joint secretary (foreigners) GVV Sarma too went unanswered. "I am very grateful to the home minister for consenting to review my case," Heehs said.
On Friday, 30 intellectuals - including historian Romila Thapar, academic Pratap Bhanu Mehta and poet and literary critic Arvind Krishna Mehrotra - had petitioned the PM and Chidambaram, asking them to review the decision. "To extend the visa would be to do the right thing for Heehs, Sri Aurobindo and India," historian Ramachandra Guha said. Former Karnataka governor and ex-home secretary TN Chaturvedi added his voice of support. "I do hope that Heehs is not hounded out like this."

Devotees say the work contains objectionable matters

The bigger question is: have we been so dulled into non-thinking by hagiographical works that we are unable to accept another view? Dismayed that other newspapers have not taken up the Peter Heehs issue seriously - it is almost as big as Salman Rushdie, MF Husain. Chidambaram must send a strong signal to religious fundamentalists: stop harassing thinkers - if you don't like their work, don't read it. Apart from 30 intellectuals, politicians from Congress and BJP are supporting Peter Heehs stay in India. PC orders review into historian's visa row: my story on Peter Heehs's needless harassment

Chidambaram to decide on Heehs' visa tomorrow Times of India TNN Apr 1, 2012, 05.12AM IST PUDUCHERRY:
Home minister P Chidambaram will review the decision to cancel the visa of American historian Peter Heehs, who wrote the controversial biography 'The Lives of Sri Aurobindo' in 2008. He will make his decision by Monday, he told reporters.
The Puducherry foreign regional registration office had told Heehs, who lives at the SriAurobindo Ashram here, that his visa, set to expire in the second week of April, would not be extended. Heehs has lived in India since the 1970s, working in the ashram archives to digitize and edit the writings of freedom fighter and spiritual leader Sri Aurobindo. 
At a press conference in New Delhi, Chidambaram said he had come to know about the FRRO decision to cancel Heeh's visa only on Saturday morning. "I have asked for a suo motu review and am told that the file would be submitted to me on Monday. I will take a decision on Monday," he said. 
Heehs' biography had created quite a furore when it was published in the US in 2008. He described it as a full-length critical biography based on primary sources that was "aimed at people who wish to approach Sri Aurobindo in a different way". 
However, some ashram residents held protests and even went to court, saying that he had made "denigrating and unacceptable remarks" about Sri Aurobindo and Mirra Alfassa, better known as the Mother.
The book received favourable reviews from experts on Sri Aurobindo studies and historians, including Jawaharlal Nehru University's Romila Thapar, Harvard University's Sugata Bose and London School of Economics' Ramachandra Guha, among others. 
Historians defend Heehs
The historians said that the protesters had not read the book but had misunderstood the content based on an unrepresentative set of extracts . The historians sent representations on March 31 to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Chidambaram, asking them "to intervene and grant Heehs his visa at the earliest, so that he is not forced to leave our shores by April 15, as presently threatened" . They also quoted a letter by rural development minister Jairam Ramesh, who has read and deeply appreciated the book. 
"Mr Heehs' biography of Sri Aurobindo, justifiably commended by Shri Jairam Ramesh (as well as by scholars around the world), is among the finest ever written of a major Indian nationalist and spiritualist... It would be greatly to the detriment of our country to be seen as having driven out an internationally recognised scholar who is committed to writing biography and history of the highest calibre," they wrote. 
Mr. Heehs, author of the book ‘The Lives of Sri Aurobindo', had drawn the ire of a section of the spiritual leader's devotees who say the work contains objectionable matters.
The ostensible reason being his ninth book, The Lives of Sri Aurobindo. For years, religious fundamentalists have been harassing Heehs over his non-hagiographic and more academic treatment of Sri Aurobindo's well-received biography.
Home minister P Chidambaram on Saturday asked for a review of an order denying American historian Peter Heehs a visa extension. Heehs, who has been living in India for the past 41 years, was abruptly told by the foreigners' registration office (FRO) in ...
Home Minister P Chidambaram will review the decision on cancellation of the visa of a US historian Peter Heehs, living in Puducherry, and will take a decision on it by Monday. Heehs was asked to leave the country after he had spent nearly ...
The ostensible reason for the non-extension of Heehs's visa, according to sources, is his ninth book, 'The Lives of Sri Aurobindo'. For years, a handful of religious fundamentalists have been harassing Heehs over his treatment of Sri Aurobindo's ...

The topic of workshop was “DEVELOPMENT OF TRAINING MODULE FOR EDUCATIONAL MANAGERS BASED ON SRI AUROBINDO'S PHILOSOPHY”
Two days workshop was organised by the Shri Aurobindo Studies Centre
Updated: 2012-03-30:17-32-12 N4E correspondent Lucknow: 
A two days workshop was  organised by the Shri Aurobindo Studies Centre under the Department of Education, University of Lucknow on 29.03.12 and 30.03.12. The topic of workshop was  “DEVELOPMENT OF TRAINING MODULE FOR EDUCATIONAL MANAGERS BASED ON SRI AUROBINDO’S PHILOSOPHY”. 
The workshop was inaugurated by Shri R.K. Mittal  (Retired IAS). He was the  chief guest at the inaugural session.  Dr. Varun Vidyarthi was the special guest and the program was presided by Prof. Akhilesh chaube, Head, Department of Education, Universitry of Lucknow. 
Welcome lecture was delivered by Prof. Subodh Kumar, Dean, Faculty of Education, Universitry of Lucknow and vote of thank was given by Prof. Amita Bajpai, co-coordinater of the workshop. 
The objective of that workshop was to  incorporate important  suggestions to develop a training module for managers of various private and public educational institutions. 30 participants from various educational institutions participated in the workshop.

We are aspiring that all Sri Aurobindo and the Mother works would be available for download in the contemporary digital format so it would be possible to carry...
Sri Aurobindo describes this process: “This would continue until the point was reached at which Overmind would begin itself to be transformed into Supermind; the supramental consciousness and force would take up the transformation directly ...
Here is Sri Aurobindo's answer, the best that can be given to the second question: “Cast away from you these movements of doubt, depression and the rest ...
Sri Aurobindo's power is so much with them, with the experiences · The breath of revelatory prophecy is extraordinary—the Mother · In the Realms of Gold—The...