Saturday, March 24, 2012

Manoj Das invited for public discussion in Cuttack April Conference

Letter to Manoj Das from the People of Odisha Posted by General Editor at 3/24/2012 12:24:00 PM March 22, 2012
Dear Shri Manoj Das,
You have been at the forefront in criticising Peter Heehs’ insulting book on Sri Aurobindo. You were the first to identify and present to the public more than 90 perverse passages from this book which you said are damaging to Sri Aurobindo and to His Ashram. Subsequently the Government of Odisha proscribed the book exposing its perverse contents and malicious communal intent.
But now we find that you are telephoning Devotees in Odisha and members of political parties in Odisha to tell them that there is nothing wrong with the book and that everybody should keep quiet and do nothing about it!
You know very well that recently the Trustees of the Ashram abused and misbehaved with the People of Odisha. Since then the matter has been raised in the Odisha Assembly and the evidence has been broadcast on television. Yet you are now telling the People of Odisha that the Trustees of the Ashram did not do anything wrong!
Dear Shri Manoj Das, we the People of Odisha have always respected you because of your love for Sri Aurobindo and your deep scholarship of His writings. But if you now betray Sri Aurobindo, on what basis shall we continue to respect you? If not for Him, what is there that is great about you or anybody else? We ask you to come out in a public declaration of your position on the book and on the question of the self-respect of the People of Odisha.
1.      Do you believe that insulting Sri Aurobindo in his own Ashram should be accepted quietly and meekly by all His children and by the Devotees of Odisha?
2.      Do you oppose the proscription of the book by the Government of Odisha?
3.      Do you believe the People of Odisha should be insulted by the Trustees of the Ashram, and that they should not demand apology from the Trustees and accept their abuse meekly and helplessly?
Dear Manoj Das, some of us have heard you say that you are helpless in this matter since you depend entirely on the Trustees of the Ashram for your food, housing and especially medical expenses, and hence you are forced to follow their orders even though your conscience is hurting you in doing these wrong things.
If you stand for the truth and speak for Sri Aurobindo’s interests instead of the Trustees interests, we the People of Odisha assure you that we will take care of all your medical expenses and all other needs without any compromise – because we love Sri Aurobindo.
We would also like to invite you to a public discussion on this matter during the April Conference in Cuttack so that you can clear all our doubts in one sitting. Please reply to us soon. With respects and regards. For the People of Odisha (Translation of Letter in Oriya reproduced below)

Both sides have done something remarkable; the MDFS by emphacising on the extraordinary personality that is Manoj Das, and the latter by gracing the occasion and enlightening the organizers (instead of saying “I am not supposed to be moved by such small emotions and I have to ignore any such event that tries to glorify me”). There have been fans & admirers of Manoj Das since decades; they might not have been formally organized but their love & respect for him was no less. But that generation is being replaced by one which knows more of ‘fast food literates’ than personalities like Manoj Das, and on this backdrop the event organized at New Delhi holds special/symbolic significance. 

Privileging people before abstractions

Herbert Spencer and the Invention of Modern Life by Mark Francis: A stunning revelation of a personality and thinker about whom even most well informed Victorianists evaluate largely from misinformation. This book presents an entirely new understanding of Spencer. --Frank M. Turner, John Hay Whitney Professor of History, Yale University 4:40 PM

Adam Smith: An Enlightened Life
by Nicholas Phillipson 
Smith saw himself primarily as a philosopher rather than an economist and would never have predicted that the ideas for which he is now best known were his most important. This book shows the extent to which The Wealth of Nations and Smith’s other great work, The Theory of Moral Sentiments, were part of a larger scheme to establish a grand “Science of Man,” one of the most ambitious projects of the European Enlightenment, which was to encompass law, history, and aesthetics as well as economics and ethics, and which was only half complete on Smith’s death in 1790. 
Nicholas Phillipson reconstructs Smith’s intellectual ancestry and shows what Smith took from, and what he gave to, in the rapidly changing intellectual and commercial cultures of Glasgow and Edinburgh as they entered the great years of the Scottish Enlightenment. Above all he explains how far Smith’s ideas developed in dialogue with those of his closest friend, the other titan of the age, David Hume. (20101018) 4:51 PM

I should realize that where ‘taller personalities’ got things wrong – Ptolemy, Newton, Einstein, et. al. – there is scope for me to inquire / inspect on my own whether there may be other right paths / doctrines. Viswa [sbicitizen]

The Mother once lucubrated on the difference between geniuses and mystics.  Her answer may help us understand why it is that sages, who have attained Enlightenment and are supposed to be in constant union with the Supreme Divine, do not possess the unique spectacular talents that are often displayed by geniuses, why they are not found resolving unsolved math problems, painting like Picasso, playing chess like grandmasters, or discovering novel groundbreaking drugs.  
“It is a disease of the ordinary human intellect—which comes, moreover, from separation, division—to make a thing always either this or that. If you choose this, you turn your back on that; if you choose that, you turn your back on this. It is an impoverishment. One must know how to take up everything, combine everything, synthesise everything. And then one has an integral realisation.” Collected Works of the Mother, vol. 9, pp 90-95. (online)

Michael Polanyi (1891–1976): The reductionistic attempt to reduce higher level realities into lower level realities generates what Polanyi describes as a moral inversion, in which the higher is rejected in favour of the lower. This inversion is pursued with moral passion. Polanyi identifies it as a pathology of the modern mind, and traces its origins to a false conception of knowledge; which although relatively harmless in the formal sciences, generates nihilism in the humanities. Wikipedia  

Michael Polanyi has so extensively described, it is faith that guides us to the potentially fruitful question -- one that can be asked "in good faith," and to which we can anticipate an answer to be forthcoming. For example, "Newton doubted the traditional theory of 'gravity,' but he believed in the unity of the world.... Doubt set his thought...

Karl Polanyi understood by economic change, since we were looking for a more positive construction than a simple negation; and this is where the idea of a human economy came from. What makes an economy “human”? First, it privileges people before abstractions. People make and remake their economic lives and that has to be the basis for thinki... On profit and rent in the history of capitalism from The Memory Bank - Dec 14, 2011 11:00 AM
Marx nor Polanyi (who had less excuse to miss it almost a century later) saw the social consequences of converting the class struggle that animated the liberal revolutions into a form of bureaucratic capitalism based on an alliance between the capitalists and the enforcers. But Weber did, with the Prussian junkers and Rhineland capitalists under... The resurgence of the civic from The Immanent Frame - Nov 30, 2011 2:15 AM
Karl Polanyi first argued. By sundering material objects from moral meaning and symbolic significance, disembedded capital de-sacralizes the shared reality we all inhabit and reduces everything to tradable commodities. And by separating financial from ethical value and measuring all things according to nominal monetary worth, global finance gr... 

I just finished watching a video of a debate on religion with Christopher Hitchens on BookTV. I enjoy watching debates like this because it challenges our myths about society, culture and reality. Speaking of myths, I think that Savitri Era Open Forum: If Joseph Campbell was alive today, he would be cheering on Dennett, Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens by ~C4Chaos September 18, 2007

Why not take Hume’s model of human nature instead? For Hume, humans are defined at the most fundamental level by sympathy towards others, not self-interest. This makes sense empirically in terms of what we actually observe, from an evolutionary perspective in terms of our closest primate relatives (bonobos and chimps), and psychogenetically in terms of how persons develop in a social world from infancy on. For Hume the problem isn’t “how can we overcome individualist self-interest so as to enter into cooperative relations?”, but rather “how can we break with the partiality of sympathies (tribalism/kinship relations) to form sympathies outside our immediate network of fellows?”
Many religions here would be a part of the problem because they often reinforce tribalistic, exclusionary relations rather than opening on to broader communities. Taking another tack, there’s also Spinoza: “Nothing is more useful to man than man” (Ethics, Part IV). My fellows are my self-interest. The are part of my happiness, help me in my work, part of my safety, they are my prosperity in the world, etc.
At any rate, it strikes me as strange to suggest that religion is the only thing that can draw people together in a common project. I also find the idea of a “common body” a bit horrifying (so many ugly historical resonances with these desires vis a vis nationalism and religion). People are drawn together by problems. Problems can come from all sorts of places. Moreover, we see people drawn together all the time by politics, collaborative work, conversation, love, celebration, building, etc.

I think the God of philosophers and theologians is something quite different than the God of popular religion. There’s always something a bit devious in the work of philosophers and theologians when discussing God. They turn everything upside down and inside out. I teach a lot of theology in my classes and have noticed over the years that my students are far more troubled by the theologies of Descartes or Thomas than the atheisms of Lucretius and Dennett (and remember I’m in an extremely religious part of the country). Why is this? These theologies are more corrosive to their religious beliefs than anything the atheists write. They can just take up a position of opposition with respect to the atheists, but with the theologians…
Now there’s a challenge! Now suddenly their Biblically and Church inspired beliefs are challenged by a rational analysis of the essence of God and what would have to follow from this essence. Part of my point here is that we should take great care, I think, not to confuse academic discourses about God with religion. When discussing religion I think we should discuss what the people believe and do, not how the theologians and philosophers rationalize this.

Instead of tying religion to belief/s in the supernatural, what about understanding religion as primarily rooted in non-ordinary realities and/or forms of experience? This is what Robert Bellah does in his most recent book “Religion in Human Evolution” (2011), drawing on Alfred Schutz’s notion of “multiple realities.” There is the world/reality of daily life, which is the world of working, of rational response to anxiety and need–but this is not the only reality humans inhabit. Indeed, no one can live in that world all the time, and as Bellah points out, some can’t live in it at all: we see them wandering city streets, homeless. Religious realities are not the only non-ordinary realities: football is a good example of how ordinary space and time can be transcended for the sake of a game. Then there are the realities of TV, movies, plays, music, daydreams…
Bellah writes: “the notion that the world of daily life is uniquely real is itself a fiction that is maintained only with effort. The world of daily life, like all the other multiple realities, is socially constructed. Each culture, each era, constructs its own world of daily life, never identical with any other. Even the meaning of ‘standard’ time and space differs subtly between cultures, and fundamental conceptions of person, family, and nation are all culturally variable. By this I do not mean that the world of daily life even in its cultural variability is not real–it is real enough. But it lacks the unique ontological reality, the claim to be perfectly natural, that it seeks to secure when it puts in brackets the doubt that it could be other. It is one of the functions of other realities to remind us that the bracketing is finally insecure and unwarranted. Occasionally a work of art will break its bounds, will deeply unsettle us, will even issue us the command ‘Change your life’–that is, it will claim not a subordinate reality but a higher reality than the world of daily life” (p. 4).
Bellah goes on to suggest that science and religion in their own ways can issue such commands, as well. Religious realities in particular he connects to the feeling of an infinite Whole generated by a participatory relation (rather than manipulative, as in the world of daily life) to the Cosmos. Of course, all these realities overlap and cut across one another at various points. This generates symbolism, the capacity for ordinary things to point beyond themselves, to remind us of other forms of consciousness, other realities. Bellah ends up rooting religion in play and ritual. He argues that play has no biological significance, though it can of course be understood as adaptive in any number of ways. It primary significance, though, is that play is an end in itself, rather than a means to something else. Bellah rejects the notion that religion can be understood primarily in terms of propositions and beliefs, which seems to be what you want to do. Instead, he connects it experience, expression, and again, to the way symbolism, once expressed, can feedback upon experience to reshape it.

There are millions of believers out there that see the supernatural– whether in the moderate form of just positing and transcendent God or the strong form of demons, possessions, miracles, etc –as absolutely crucial and central to religion. Descriptions such as this, I think, are just attempts to sanitize religion. That is, I think the intellectual that is religiously inclined sets about cleaning up religion in theorizing it because they are embarrassed by this extremely common supernatural element. In my view, though, when analyzing a phenomenon we go with those beliefs that are statistically dominant in a population, not with rationalizations we’d like to be true. Moreover, if it is true that religion is just about “non-ordinary experiences”, then why call it religious at all? Certainly we all have non-ordinary experiences yet many of us feel no need to describe these things as religious.

Our worth lies only in the measure of our effort to exceed ourselves, and to exceed ourselves is to attain the Divine. -The Mother (1973)

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Evaluation of positions is infinitely deferred

The central problem with religion is that it ties us to authority– the authority of texts, figures, priests, and institutions –as the condition of political organization and what is right and good. As such, it inscribes servitude in the very structure of political action. Even in a leftist variant, such a structure is still, to use Deleuze and Guattari’s term, organized around micro-fascist desires. Why not instead envision community, collectivity, and action that arises from people themselves? I honestly don’t get it and am sure I’ll be beat up for asking whether such people literally believe the things two paragraph above.
There will be weasel words, rationalizations, gymnastics, and all sorts of contortions as to how there’s something more going on here. But for the life of me, if you don’t believe there’s something supernatural here, why call it religion and why associate yourself with such a thing? The same goes for talk about “spirituality” too. Newsflash. I think things are interconnected too. I’m filled with wonder and joy at the beauty of this. I wonder at the vastness of the universe. Yet I wouldn’t describe any of this as “spiritual” or “religious”. So what’s this all about?

I’m literally horrified by the fact that collectively we have knowledge (and I’m not making any bullshit, postmodern qualifications about this) or that an argument is better than another, and the fact that changes nothing. We know yet nothing changes. It drives me nuts. We have the better argument (and no, I’m not saying I always have the better argument, though narcissistically I suffer from the flaw of thinking I do) and it doesn’t persuade. It drives me nuts. I’m horrified by this. My horror first began with how the American public responded following 9-11 (especially in the lead up to the Iraq war). It’s grown worse and worse in the intervening years as I’ve watched growing religious fanaticism (which is mainstream Christianity in the States… Sorry Episcopals, UU’s, and UCC’s, you’re the minority), as I’ve watched mainstream responses to our economic problems, as I watch the way in which environmental issues are shuffled off the table. It drives me crazy. No matter how much psychoanalysis I learn, no matter how much ideology critique I learn, it never ceases to amaze me. I never cease to be shocked at how bad our decision making processes are; at how bad our long-term reasoning is; at how malicious we can be. Hence my love of the Stoics and Epicureans: 

The frustrating thing I encounter among continentals again and again is that all too often (a statistical claim), it seems impossible for there to be a genuine disagreement over positions. If one says “I disagree with X on Y because of Z”, the general response is “you’ve misinterpreted X.” In other words, it seems as if the texts of figures are endlessly transformed into Midas’ labyrinth, where the figure being discussed is granted sovereign authority and is the only one permitted to articulate positions and where any evaluation of positions is infinitely deferred behind interpretive disputes. […]
A number of us Continentals have abominable style as well (I’m looking at you Hegel, Derrida, Lacan, Deleuze, and Adorno). Yes, yes, I know some folks delight at the “poetry” of these guys. I don’t. I generally read these thinkers despite their style, not for their style. In this regard, it’s perfectly appropriate to ask for clarity. I know the arguments as to why these styles are necessary. Nonetheless, you’re still asking readers to invest their time. You should take some time in return.
So what, then, would a vivid style be for me? A vivid style– and I doubt Graham will agree here –would be something between the arresting and mind thrilling pyrotechnics of Zizek, Dennett, and Bennett with their examples, humor, and thought experiments, the poetry of Lacan, Derrida, Deleuze, and the rigor and clarity of Hegel, Quine, Sellars, Spinoza, Parfit, and Priest. Somehow it would manage to synthesize all of this in writing. However, above all, such a writing would also always be centered on the extra-philosophical importance of what it is discussing: the ethical, the political, the existential… The “why it matters”. 

The fallacy of mood affiliation by Tyler Cowen on March 31, 2011 Recently I wrote: It seems to me that people are first choosing a mood or attitude, and then finding the disparate views which match to that mood and, to themselves, justifying those views by the mood… 1:47 PM 

As I have said before, at the center of all psychological denial is a hidden agenda. That agenda is usually not completely conscious--meaning that the denier has not thought through the issues surrounding his denial; and may not even be aware of what his motivation is in asserting something is true when it isn't; or false when it isn't. The entire act of denial about this economy was initiated to justify continuing to spend wildly the taxpayers' money and not have to do anything to slow down that spending because they "hoped" and "wished" that things would get better by doning nothing but spending even more…
Their denial is reflexive and completely willful at this point. They simply refuse to accept reality because the consequences are too excruciatingly painful to contemplate (both with regard to their image of themselves and to the country they were elected to preserve and protect). Since they have no facts to back up their present stance, they must resort to rhetorical ploys and logical fallacies to make their opposition look like they "hate the poor"; or are "racist" etc. etc. blah blah blah.Kkk

Rethinking secularism: Open thread: the power of religion in the public sphere posted by Ruth Braunstein and David Kyuman Kim Four of the world’s leading public intellectuals came together yesterday in the historic Great Hall at Cooper Union to discuss “Rethinking Secularism.” The Immanent Frame
In an electrifying symposium convened by the Institute for Public Knowledge at NYU, the Social Science Research Council and the Humanities Institute at Stony Brook University, Judith Butler, Jürgen Habermas, Charles Taylor, and Cornel West gave powerful accounts of religion in the public sphere. As Craig Calhoun summarized in his closing remarks, the four speakers addressed in different ways the problem of the secular. For Taylor and Habermas, this is centrally the challenge of inhabiting a common world without universally shared absolutes, and of respecting the past while maintaining openness to the future. Butler emphasized the need to start from alterity and the recognition of non-belonging. West added the centrality of poetry, prophecy and empathy for suffering.

What this situation, of the absence of 'Grace' and 'Avatar' in its deeper occult connotation, means is that, Sri Aurobindo is more than his works, prose or poetry, including perhaps his Savitri. 
Re: What Jugal told me about Record of Yoga by RY Deshpande on Sun 18 Mar 2012 07:33 AM IST Profile |  Permanent Link
And again in Savitri itself we should be careful not to mix up things. For instance, the Book of Yoga in Savitri, Book Seven, is specifically meant for Savitri, and not for you and me, certainly not for me, not even for Aswapati. Ditto for Record of Yoga, and other related writings.

Groomed in a modern academic tradition and post-Enlightenment ideals of creative freedom and social critique, Sri Aurobindo (1872-1950) turned his attention to yoga and the limits of consciousness in its ability to relate to and transform nature. In the process, he documented scrupulously his experiments and experiences based on a synergistic existential framework of practice. Debashish Banerji correlates the approach to yoga Sri Aurobindo took in his diaries with his later writings, to derive a description of human subjectivity and its powers. Banerji constellates Sri Aurobindo's approach with transpersonal psychology and contemporary lineages of phenomenology and ontology, to develop a transformative yoga psychology redefining the boundaries and possibilities of the human and opening up lines of self-practice towards a wholeness of being and becoming.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Matrubhaban, Cuttack Conference from April 4-7

It gives me immense pleasure to announce that on 12 March 2012 Overman Foundation has published its eighth book ‘The Alipore Bomb Trial: Selected Documents’. A sequel to our earlier publication ‘The Alipore Bomb Trial Judgment’, this book includes a number of unpublished documents of the Alipore Bomb Trial like Confessions of the Chief Accused, Statements of the Accused in the Lower Court further to their Confessions, Examination of the Accused Further to their Confessions, Petitions Presented to the Court of Sessions, Opinions of Assessors and High Court Appeal along with the First Information Report of the trial.                                                                                                
Compiled and edited by Shri Anurag Banerjee, ‘The Alipore Bomb Trial: Selected Documents’ comprises of 200 pages and is available at a price of Rs. 290 (Two Hundred and Ninety) only.
To place an order, please write to the following email address: overmanfoundation@gmail.com Payment can also be made online.
With warm regards, Anurag Banerjee
Founder-Chairman, Overman Foundation.

 Auroville Radio Editor's Notes Subscribe to the newsletter Dear readers,
It has been a truly uplifting week for us here at Auroville as the Tantidhatri International Women's Performing Arts Festival brought together several inspirational women from over the world on one stage. In this edition, we share with you their performances and talks and hope you get a flavor of the joy. Also this week, our News section features some important programs for those of you interested in the ongoing development of Auroville. Organization of the Matrimandir Srimoyi is talking about the organization of the Matrimandir in Auroville and about the difficulties her team is facing.

All Orissa Sri Aurobindo Study Circle Conference 4th to 7th April Matrubhaban, Cuttack - Om Namo Bhagabate Sri Aurobindayah
42nd ALL ORISSA SRI AUROBINDO STUDY CIRCLE CONFERENCE 2012
4th, 5th, 6th & 7th April MATRUBHABAN SRI AUROBINDO MARG CUTTACK - 753 013 Tel : (0671) 2344338, 9437023407, 9437120220 e-mail: matrubhaban@bsnl.in Please visit us at : www.motherorissa.com Dear Sir / Madam,
"42nd All Orissa Sri Aurobindo Study Circle Conference'' will be held during 4th to 7th April 2012 at Matrubhaban, Cuttack as per the Programme given below. The Conference will be inaugurated on 4th April at 5.30P.M. Prof. Biswanath Ray from Calcutta and exponents on The Mother & Sri Aurobindo from in & outside the state will participate in this conference. You are requested to kindly attend with other members of your Study Circle. Yours Sincerely Members Matrubhaban
04.04.2012 (Wednesday)
05.30 pm March Past (Members of all zones are requested to participate in white uniform) Vande Mataram Opening of Exhibition
06.00 pm - 06.15 pm Collective Meditation around Samadhi
06.30 pm - 08.30 pm INAUGURAL SESSION Meditation with Mother’s Music Recitation from Savitri Dr. Shyama Kanungo
Welcome Address Sri Nityananda Samantray
Opening of Souvenir
Introduction Sri Gadadhar Mishra
Inaugural Address Prof. Biswanath Ray
Speakers Dr. Archana Nayak
Prof. Mohapatra Nilamani Sahu
Subject Is the world preparing for a big change?
08.30 pm - 09.00 pm Cultural Programme
05.04.2012 (Thursday)
08.30 am - 12.00 noon MORNING SESSION Discussion  from SABCL-24
Introduction Prof. Biswanath Ray
Letters on The Mother Sri Mahendra Nath Swain, Sri Pravakar Mishra, Smt. Kanaklata Mohanty, Smt. Rita Chand, Sri Purna Chandra Mohapatra, Sri Ramesh Ch. Sahu, Sk. Abdul Kasam, Sri Saroj Kanta Mishra […]

Mind-Body Medicine and Beyond Date: Jun 16, 2012 Venue: VAN NIWAS Himalayan Centre of Sri Aurobindo Ashram -- Delhi Branch Bara Patthar NAINITAL

29 March 1914 is a momentous event in the annals of spirituality

The Mother’s Work—A Radio Talk by RY Deshpande on Wed 21 Mar 2012 03:30 AM IST Permanent Link A Talk on All India Radio Pondicherry: 21 February 2001, 9:15 PM
The Mother came to India to meet Sri Aurobindo. Destiny had brought them together in the fulfilment of its divine objective. Their meeting on 29 March 1914 must be taken as a momentous event in the annals of spirituality…
Since 1926 the Mother took charge of the Ashram and gave to it another direction, worked on a wider basis for universalisation of their achievements. Practical aspect of the collective spiritual life is a necessary concern to create and shape the future. 
She was now “at the centre of the organization”. At that time, in 1927, there were just 30 disciples but in less than two years the number increased to 90, with seventeen houses for their stay. Presently there are about 2000 disciples in the Ashram. People came from all the walks of life, men and women, elderly persons and the young, from different parts of India and from distant foreign lands, they with varying backgrounds and qualifications, writers, poets, painters, musicians, thinkers, philosophers, doctors, engineers, bureaucrats, business-men,—accomplished souls aspiring to live a life in the wonder and greatness of the spirit. 
The Mother had to take care of them all. She had to organise services to look after such a large family with diverse interests and with different expectations, though the central aim was the spiritual. Soon she created a number of departments and attended to their daily essential problems. This was done with a twofold purpose: organization and work as a part of the sadhana. Thus were created several departments such as Reception, Dining Room, Bakery, Laundry, Domestic Services, Health Care, Buildings, Electrical, Workshop, Furniture, Gardens, Agricultural Farms, Dairies, Tailoring, Cobblery, Weaving, Cycle Shop, Hair Saloon and such many services. Along with these also grew Music, Painting, Poetry, Embroidery, Dancing, Drama, Theatre, Photography, Physical Culture, Cottage Industries, Printing Press, Publications, and so on. And all this had to be done within the limited resources available at the time. 
Work as a necessary aspect of spiritual growth was the truth that found its place in the scheme of things deeply spiritual. Sadhana through work gives a certain solidity and equipoise, and prepares the base more luminously. By it the will in action opens out to higher consciousness, bringing perfection to it, to things of nature which must change. Similarly, in another sense, to express the creative delight through music, painting, poetry was important, and great attention was paid towards this, these as means of spiritual-inner growth. Nothing is considered trivial or out of place. During the anxious and turbulent period of the Second World War another situation arose, and the Mother had to start a School for the children of the disciples who had come to the Ashram…
Enlarging on the Ashram experiment, the Mother moved to the larger humanity, a preparatory step towards the new race capable of manifesting the Divine ideal. She was already 90 when she initiated the Auroville project, but it was with such enthusiasm that as if she was in her full joyous youthful vigour… On 21 February 1971 the Mother initiated the project of Matrimandir as a living symbol of Auroville’s aspiration for the Divine, a unique place in the wilderness of man’s hopes and struggles. Matrimandir is the Soul of Auroville. If the Ashram and Auroville were the preparatory projects initiated by the Mother, their true fulfilment is to be seen in the New World she was preparing to make a reality here on earth.

Health, Science and Dance by Hamish  Friday, 16 March 201 auroville radio
Announcing a 5 day Wind/Solar Hybrid Workshop. A presentation of Bharatnatyam Classical Dance is being offered with images of Ashwini's oil paintings. A salutogenetic communication group will be formed to discuss our total health. The University Of Human Unity Seminar will discuss Transhumanism. Can science heal humanity and conquer death? Will we create super-humans, or monsters? Sri Aurobindo and The Mother advocate Integral Yoga. Science advocates biomedicine and technology. Are we to become Spiritual Beings, or chip enhanced cyborgs?
For nearly forty years behind the wholly good I was weakly in constitution; I suffered constantly from the smaller and greater ailments and mistook this curse for a burden that Nature had laid upon me. When I renounced the aid of medicines, then they began to depart from me like disappointed parasites. Only then did I understand what a mighty force the natural health within me and how much mightier yet the Will and Faith exceeding mind which God meant to be the divine support of our life in this body.

Mind-Body Medicine and Beyond Date: Jun 16, 2012 Venue: VAN NIWAS Himalayan Centre of Sri Aurobindo Ashram -- Delhi Branch Bara Patthar NAINITAL

Hindi translation of ‘SMRITI KATHA’ is being published in ADITI. Serially. Wonderful authentic document of history! Must read. Suresh Tyagi

Language, Nation and Narration WRITING INDIA, WRITING ENGLISH By G.J.V. Prasad, Routledge , New Delhi, Delhi, 2011. pp. 176, 545.00 Anjana Sharma
Before I begin the review of G.J.V. Prasad's work a word on the dust jacket cover: it speaks of the multicultural, multilingual, multifarious ways in which English is read, written, and spoken in India. Hence, fish swim in a sea of words taken from Hindi, Tamil and English, the fish possibly being us who swim in the multitudinous seas that make up the many currents of English usage in India today and of yore. Artera

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Everyone believes what they want to in a post-fact world

The fallacy of mood affiliation by Tyler Cowen on March 31, 2011 at 8:43 am in Philosophy Permalink Recently I wrote:
It seems to me that people are first choosing a mood or attitude, and then finding the disparate views which match to that mood and, to themselves, justifying those views by the mood.  I call this the “fallacy of mood affiliation,” and it is one of the most underreported fallacies in human reasoning.  (In the context of economic growth debates, the underlying mood is often “optimism” or “pessimism” per se and then a bunch of ought-to-be-independent views fall out from the chosen mood.)
Here are some further examples:
1. People who strongly desire to refute those who predicted the world would run out of innovations in 1899 and thus who associate proponents of a growth slowdown with that far more extreme view.  There’s simply an urgent feeling that any “pessimistic” view needs to be countered.
2. People who see a lot of net environmental progress (air and water are cleaner, for instance) and thus dismiss or downgrade well-grounded accounts of particular environmental problems.  There’s simply an urgent feeling that any “pessimistic” view needs to be countered.
3. People who see a political war against the interests of the poor and thus who are reluctant to present or digest analyses which blame some of the problems of the poor on…the poor themselves. (Try bringing up “predatory borrowing” in any discussion of “predatory lending” and see what happens.)   There’s simply an urgent feeling that any negative or pessimistic or undeserving view of the poor needs to be countered.
4. People who see raising or lowering the relative status of Republicans (or some other group) as the main purpose of analysis, and thus who judge the dispassionate analysis of others, or for that matter the partisan analysis of others, by this standard.  There’s simply an urgent feeling that any positive or optimistic or deserving view of the Republicans needs to be countered.
In the blogosphere, the fallacy of mood affiliation is common.

Let’s not count the poor from Kafila by Shivam Vij
As someone recently commented on a Kafila post, we live in a post-fact world where there are no facts. Everyone believes what they want to. So depending on your ideology, poverty in India has reduced or increased. But such is the debate on poverty that the definition of poverty itself is subject to debate. How poor do you have to be, so that the government will say you are poor? This poverty debate has been on around the same lines for about ten years now, with the economic left arguing that India isn’t shining, and the economic centre-right arguing that millions of people have been lifted out of poverty by India’s super-successful economic growth. The debate will go on forever, there will be no certainty in numbers, and perhaps there shouldn’t be – perhaps counting the poor cheapens the issue of poverty.

In Spiritual circles, it is very easy to talk of “nicey-nicey” stuff which looks appealing but is Spiritual nonsense.  Just add in some buzzwords and say something that helps one feel good and placated and you have a best-seller and winner on your hand.  But if Spiritual journey and your longing to know is more than Entertainment for you, then you need to look at everything carefully and ruthlessly. It is very common amongst the religious to look for “Healing” as a sign of the “greatness” of a Saint… Quite honestly, this obsession with healing by Sages has completely screwed up the entire Spiritual World… But there is an entire industry out there for healing.  And it passes off as Spiritual work.

Is it possible for curing much serious illnesses (like cancer, aids etc) by puryfying the vital body? As illustrated above i believe that there would be a reason behind every illness. So if we are able to nullify the real cause behind that illness, then there is no reason for a particular illness to exist in the body. Allopathic method of treatment involves treating the effect of an illness (Say-A) but the real reason of an illness may go unchecked and this reason could manifest again as another illness (Say B).
Reference to the descent of force i am wondering whether this descent would make the vital body & circumconcient more resistant against any attacks.(Also if attacked this shakti can flush out unwanted energies from the body-May be this could happen in the later stages of descent not in the initial phase )

Comment posted by Govind Re: What Jugal told me about Record of Yoga 20 March 2012
The gospel of "find thy hid soul", the call of the inner divine, is the one thing that answers to the need for self-fulfillment and self-affirmation that so markedly characterizes the Western personality. The twin obstacles of the vital's attraction towards siddhis and the idolatry of the lower physical mental nature (that PH and his supporters stand for) were, in the scheme of things, perhaps bound to come up and needed to be tackled by the Mother in Her pressure to liberate the Psychic even here.

Monday, March 19, 2012

Peter Heehs has stirred a hornet's nest

Public stir over failure to ban disputed book - Article Window times of india 2 Jan 2012 – Public stir over failure to ban disputed book
Aurobindo Ashram Inmates Divided Over Content. Bosco Dominique TNN Puducherry:
For the first time in the history of Sri Aurobindo Ashram, a section of inmates launched a public protest on Sunday against the ashram management.
    They protested against the failure to take action against fellow inmate Peter Heehs for making “denigrating and unacceptable remarks” on Sri Aurobindo and his spiritual collaborator, Mirra Alfassa, better known as the Mother, in his biography on the philosopher. Even as 12 inmates staged a silent protest, another section of inmates defended the book saying, it had received favourable reviews from experts in Aurobindo studies and the ashram “should not bow to pressure from fundamentalists”.
    The month-long protest between 8am and 11am daily. in front of the office of the Sri Aurobindo Trust is to seek the dismissal of the present group of trustees of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust and immediate expulsion of Peter Heehs from the ashram community. The protesters insist that the trust publicly declare that the book is factually incorrect and does not represent its views and that Peter Heehs has abused his position at the archives. They also demanded that the trust withdraw the copyright permission given to Columbia University Press.
    The book titled ‘The Lives of Sri Aurobindo’ published by Columbia University Press is available in the United States since April 2008. It stirred a hornet’s nest in India delaying its official launch here. The book triggered a series of debates in Puducherry, where the spiritual leader settled after abruptly curtailing his political career in 1910. A section of inmates submitted mass petitions to the ashram managing trustee Manoj Das Gupta in 2008 seeking a blanket ban on the book, although this book is not a publication by the ashram.
    A review by Choice, a publication of the Association of College and Research Libraries and a division of the American Library Association summed up the book as ‘essential’ for graduate students, faculty, researchers and general readers. The rival group of inmates contend that the ashram gives complete freedom to its inmates and everyone has the liberty to like or dislike a book. They argued that the protesters have not read the book but rather an unrepresentative set of “extracts” and have misunderstood certain things.
Mercifully, nobody has yet called for it to be banned but it's still early .....You can add to the list 'The Lives of Sri Aurobindo' by Peter Heehs. 
Book controversy takes an ugly turn The Hindu - ‎Feb 27, 2012‎
The issue over the controversial book on Sri Aurobindo took an ugly turn when a few of the devotees who were staging dharna outside the Ashram Trust allegedly tried to “prevent” one of the seniormost members of the Trust from entering the office and ...
150 inmates of Aurobindo Ashram on three-day dharna IBNLive.com - ‎Feb 26, 2012‎ PTI | 11:02 PM, Feb 26, 2012 Puducherry, Feb 26 (PTI)
About 150 inmates of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram here today embarked upon a three-day dharna demanding that trustees managing the ashram be dismissed immediately for their "failure" to protect its ...
Pondy ashram faces 3-day flak Deccan Chronicle - ‎Feb 26, 2012‎By S. Prasad
The Sri Aurobindo Ashram here is facing an embarrassing turmoil with a section of the inmates and devotees launching a three-day protest against the trustees of the ashram for their alleged failure to take action against inmate and US ...
Sri Aurobindo, Heehs and the fragility of faith Hindustan Times (blog) - 22 Feb 2012
This time, it's Peter Heehs, an American historian, who has who has lived in and served the Sri Aurobindo Ashram for 41 years, set up the Ashram's Archives ...
comments on Sri Aurobindo in his book 'The Lives of Sri Aurobindo', the disciples of Sri Maa and Sri Aurobindo today urged ... notification in 2009 hadbanned the book published by Colombia University Press, New York.
2008: The Lives of Sri Aurobindo by Peter Heehs ... Were it not for these bans, Muslims would riot on Rushdie's blasphemous work, the ...
Ban the ban telegraph india 30 Jul 2011 Ramachandra Guha ...
The republic of India bans books with a depressing frequency. ... Press in New York published Peter Heehs's The Lives of Sri Aurobindo. Letters to Editor 3 Aug 2011 – Of the many cases, the ban on Peter Heehs’s The Lives of Sri Aurobindo deserves special mention. The abiding appeal of this controversial book lies in its empirical depth. Proscribing a book cannot be considered the right way to deal with controversial writers… Yours faithfully,
P.B. Saha, Calcutta
The Odisha High had banned the sale and distribution of the controversial book "The Lives of Sri Aurobindo" and the home department of the state government ...
Need To Ban The Book 'The Lives Of Sri ... on 12 August, 2010 Lok Sabha Debate Indian Kanoon - Lok Sabha Debates
MATTERS UNDER RULE-377: Need To Ban The Book The Lives Of Shri ... on 12 August, 2010 Title: Need to ban the book The lives of Sri Aurobindo written by a US author, for its allegedly containing derogatory remarks against Sri Aurobindo, an Indian patriot-laid.
SHRI AMARNATH PRADHAN (SAMBALPUR): Sri Aurobindo is one of the worthiest sons of India, who was a famous freedom fighter, revolutionary, Yogi, and Philosopher started an Ashram at Puducherry. The country is proud of his world famous literary genius and mysticism. But in the book titled, The lives of Sri Aurobindo”, written by Mr. Peter Heehs, a citizen of U.S.A, attempts have been made to blemish and defame Sri Aurobindo directly & indirectly. So, I request Hon’ble Prime-Minister to take suitable step to upheld the prestige of our motherland and protect the religious sentiment of crores of devotees by banning the book of Mr. Peter Heehs. 

Sunday, March 18, 2012

The Yoga and its Objects and Record of Yoga

Re: What Jugal told me about Record of Yoga by RY Deshpande on Sun 18 Mar 2012 07:33 AM IST |  Profile |  Permanent Link
In the context of Record of Yoga we must recognize a couple of things. These records were for personal “use” in the sense that, in this way, what was experienced became realized, concrete, got fixed, writing them down gave firmness to all these. What bearing that personal “use” has for others is another matter. These experiences belong primarily to the first ten-fifteen years of Sri Aurobindo’s yoga-tapasya, and it has that historical relevance, that bearing.
After 1920 things started moving altogether in a different manner. Naturally, Sri Aurobindo himself felt that the earlier formulations had kind of become ‘dated’. That is what he means in his letter dated 28 October 1934 that what was described in the 1921 The Yoga and its Objects belongs to the earlier period of his yogic pursuit and formulation. The same of course applies to Record of Yoga, and we should not make a fetish of things… This “historical perspective” must be borne in mind when we are talking about the Yoga-related writings of Sri Aurobindo. 

How does one know what he has abandoned? SA used different terminologies and different formulations in different texts, this doesn’t necessarily mean he abandoned one for the other.
Only a few of the terms of the Sapta C turn up in Part IV of the Synthesis, though it is clear he is discussing the same material. The personal gods Krishna and Kali don’t turn up at all in the Synthesis or any of his later public writings, the book The Mother is the only place outside of the Record where he mentions the 4 Mahashaktis but says nothing of their Ishwaras, and certain things related to the sharira chatusthaya of the Record are not discussed by him anywhere before his last writings (The Supramental Manifestation). In the LD or the Synthesis, he says nothing about the avatar and in the LD there is no mention of the guru. In Savitri he mentions Overmind only once and Supermind and psychic being never.
In the commentary on the Kena Upanishads and in Part IV of the Synthesis, he mentions the 4 forms of Knowledge – vijnana, prajnana, samjnana and aajnana, but nowhere else. The point I’m making is that none of this is a proof that he discarded or abandoned something.

Finally, the siddhis and anandas spoken of in the Record are not addressed anywhere else but can clearly be seen in Sri Aurobindo and the Mother’s own functioning. Comment on The Seven Quartets of Becoming by Debashish Banerji by debbanerji from Comments for Posthuman Destinies by debbanerji 
The following paragraph is from a booklet by Peter Heehs entitled Sri Aurobindo on Hinduism and published by the Sri Aurobindo Society, ... 7:57 AM 
This kind of treatment of a female character persuaded Sri Aurobindo to comment that Nala-Damayanti is the creation of a young Vyasa when he was still under ... 
We cannot therefore agree with the view of Sri Aurobindo that “identity necessarily involves difference and the higher the identity the richer the content and the more complex its organization” (Indra Sen). This makes the conception of ... 
Sri Aurobindo, somehow or other, believes in some such concept of Yoga, but he makes it consistent with the general nature of his philosophy. Even a casual look at the main aspects of his thought will make it clear that there are ... 
He stressed that 'All this is the Brahman' (Sri Aurobindo 1939: 28 The Life Divine). 'There is only one Reality. 'An omnipresent reality is the Brahman, not an omnipresent cause of persistent illusions' (Sri Aurobindo 1939: 35 The Life ... 
Ashis Nandy, for example, absolves Sri Aurobindo's pre-modernism with these questions: “Did Sri Aurobindo symbolise the larger suffering of his society under the colonial rule? Did his attempt to speak in a new language parallel his ... 
In his wonderful book Return to the Center, Father Bede compared the goals of Sri Aurobindo's vision with that of authentic Christian mysticism: “In the integral Yoga of Sri Aurobindo matter and life and consciousness are seen to be ... 
Sri Aurobindo, Rabindranath and KC Bhattacharya have forwarded a view about a man's transcendence. ... Both Sri Aurobindo and Rabindranath have accepted a man's transcendence to the Super Man and Universal Man or 'Matter manuscC ... 
Aurobindo Ghose Unlike most of the personalities who have so far been discussed, Sri Aurobindo was never the leader of an organized reform group, but his influence was quite extensive. He can conveniently be classified together with the ... 
Comparing Vivekananda's views on the Yogas with threat of Sri Aurobindo's conception of Yoga, Subhas Chandra wrote: "Vivekananda had no doubt spoken of the need of Jnana (knowledge), Bhakti (devotion and love) and Karma (selfless ...