-
You do have a one track approach - @SavitriEraParty: This tweet owes its existence as much to technology as to the legal rights won over centuries. The content, of course, is force of the wo...1 week ago
-
People operate with diverse systems of belief and we can live with this incoherence - Political Theology: Four New Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty - Page 118 - Paul W. Kahn - 2011 - Preview - More editions In the postmodern world, the...1 month ago
Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo and The Mother.
In view of the fact that multiple anonymous comments in a thread make confusing reading and it becomes difficult to track who is telling what and to whom, only comments bearing some name/pseudonym/identity will appear in future. [TNM 011110 SEOF]
Wednesday 29 February 2012
Demonstrators are attempting to oust the Trustees
AuroMere Meditation Centre (Sri Mother and Sri Aurobindo Center ), Pallikaranai is running from 2005 under the
guidance of The Mother's Service Society (MSS), Pondicherry . Pushpanjali on the Darshan
Day - Feb-29, 2012 (Supra mental Day).
Book row: case registered post-scuffle from A critique of the book "The Lives of Sri Aurobindo"
by Peter Heehs by General Editor
The Hindu PUDUCHERRY, February
29, 2012 Dilip
Dutta, Chandi Prasad Parida
The demonstrators are attempting to oust the
Trustees of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram. Over 100 outside protesters
were bussed in from Orissa, and the escalating stridency of the demonstration
ended in the elderly Trustees being accosted, ...
The only 'solution' was to escape, to ignore the
problem, to undermine its very existence by describing the components involved
as 'illusion'. The direction of the quest was changed and consequently the
goal; Sri Aurobindo has elaborated on ...
Hamid's Cauldron: Matters Spiritual by Syed Ali Hamid
It was around that time that a friend and colleague
of mine had done his PhD. on love in the poetry of Sri Aurobindo with
me as the supervisor, and he always talked with both passion and authority on
matters spiritual, interlaced with his own ...
On conscious parenting and natural learning | Venkinesis by
Venkataraman Ramachandran
And it is exactly upon this that later its effort
for progress must be founded. Read more of Sri Aurobindo's and The
Mother's writings on conscious parenting here. Check out Sangeetha Sriram's
beautiful blogposts on natural learning here - Part ...
Educating a billion minds: is the right approach missing Washington
Times
There is an urgent need to understand education in
its deepest and widest sense. In Sri Aurobindo's words, amongst one of India ’s
greatest philosopher and thinkers:
"That alone will be a true and living education
which helps to bring out to full advantage, makes ready for the full purpose
and scope of human life all that is in the individual man, and which at the
same time helps him to enter into his right relation with the life, mind and
soul of the people to which he belongs and with that great total life, mind and
soul of humanity of which he himself is a unit and his people or nation a
living, a separate yet inseparable member."
Atimanas Divas
Devotees throng Aurobindo Ashram on `supramental
consciousness day` Deccan Herald Puducherry,Feb 29, 2012, (PTI)
Devotees today thronged
the Aurobindo Ashram here and paid homage at the memorials of Sri Aurobindo and
his spiritual collaborator, The Mother, on the occasion of the `Supramental
Consciousness day`. It was on this day in 1956 that `the Mother` is believed to
have realized the `supramental or divine consciousness` as a result of her
spiritual experiments. The Ashram was established by Aurobindo on April 24,
1926. He passed away in 1950. The Mother (Mira Alfassa), who died in November
1973, founded Aurobindo International Centre of Education in 1952 and the
international township
of Auroville , 10 km from
here, in 1968.
A critique of the book "The Lives of Sri Aurobindo"
by Peter Heehs ... Posted by General Editor at 2/29/2012 09:33:00 AM The
total number of Ashram inmates and devotees who protested silently from February 26th to 28th was around 270.
Govind Feb
17, 2012 06:06 AM "It is unfortunate that an inmate who has
enjoyed the facilities and amenities provided by the Sri Aurobindo Ashram
Trust..."
At least this confirms from the proverbial horse’s mouth that this line that we
have been hearing for more than a year from agents of the trust both on Savitri
Era Open Forum and SAICE comes directly from "the very top"
They are speaking like owners or at least
anna-daataa type father figures and openly patronizing Ashramites. Not only
that they are laying claim to property and, much worse, loyalty that rightfully
belongs exclusively to Mother Sri Aurobindo.
Do they have no concern whatever that sadhaks will
not tolerate this kind of a domineering attitude and this daylight robbery from
Mother Sri Aurobindo?
Tuesday 28 February 2012
Street Protest outside Trustee’s Office
from: sunilauro@gmail.com
date: 27 February 2012 05:20 subject: New post
A certain group of world influencing power was very
upset with the growing demand and popularity of Sri Aurobindo in the West. The
Psychology world was even introducing Sri Aurobindo in its education and they
feared that this new age movement might deface their beliefs and their
Christian power hold. To counter attack this new movement of the future and
preserve their dominance many attempts were made. They knew as long
as the Divine Mother was there in the physical in Sri Aurobindo Ashram at Pondicherry all their
attempts could be wiped out in a single stroke. And so was it, but this
time after many failures they attempted a masterful plan and succeeded. The
plan was executed in full swing after the Mother left Her physical body.
Their first leverage for the mischief was to create
a Research and Development Section along with the Archives availability, or the
possession and the control of all manuscripts. In fact all of Sri Aurobindo’s
works were already published then why the need for Research the Development to
his writings. But this was necessary to control and manifest their evil plan of
re-writing Sri Aurobindo works. In their new versions they wanted to gradually
destroy his works. Once the tampering of his works was done they have altered
his life with their new biography ‘The Lives of Sri Aurobindo’. In the
biography the alteration to his life are easily caught by open souls and by the
genuine disciples of Sri Aurobindo. The perverted intention of the
author is caught. But in the tampering of the books, this is not easily
detected, you can’t catch where you are being mislead. The untruth has made its
house in the truth now in the new versions of the works of Sri Aurobindo. They
have succeeded in their mission of the war against the truth, their war against
Sri Aurobindo.
In the story or the history of this was well
executed was through the well known human weaknesses. Their first target was
Jayantilal Bhai, through whom this section the Archives Department of Research
and Development was set up. The lady whose influence was working well on the
male subject had done the ground work and this time a young man was chosen for
the task. So Peter arrived in India
and as suggested by this lady to Jayantllal he was made to enter and work in
this Archives and Research Department, and then what happened we all know. This
younger man with his athletic background became popular in sports and races and
well adapted in the mingling of the community. What was his purpose only his
organisers and sponsors knew. And he has delivered well to them.
During this process there had been many an awakened
souls who stood against this injustice to Sri Aurobindo. But they were all
conquered by their well planning and methodical workings. In the early eighties
the acts happening in the Archives were being reported to Pranob Da of the
Ashram, after being convinced he had ordered Kittu Reddy to take action with a
bunch of 50 young boys and ransack the department as he himself was
handicapped. But nothing happened. Jugul Kishore Mukherjee the pillar of Sri
Aurobindo International Centre of Education fought pleadingly with the managing
Trustees thinking they will do their job but only to be rebuked, slapped and
threatened in return. All the warriors failed as they relied on the Ashram
management to intervene and complete the job, little did they know that in the
evil doers with their well planning and huge funds had sealed all doors through
which their attack on Sri Aurobindo could go unfruitful.
At present there are a group of people demanding
justice by sitting outside on the street of the Ashram’s Trustee’s Office
protesting in a gathering of silence in a prayer for some miracle.
Posted to AURO1@yahoogroups.com on
Mon, 27 Feb 2012
This time, SR and co have got permission for 3 days,
and have arranged a large number of persons to come from Orissa/Bengal (around
a 100) to participate in the dharna. A Marriage Hall has been arranged for
their meals and briefing sessions. This time, even fewer known persons and
Ashramites are involved in the dharna. The faces of the people sitting are
largely unknown, and are clearly not resident of the Ashram/Pondy town. (photo
attached) … This morning’s incidents have shattered the myth of
silent dharna and leave no more doubts regarding the true intentions of its
putative leaders and organizers. It looks like a ploy to deliberately create a
law-and-order problem. Ajit, Arindam, Bulu, Gautam
These leaked emails expose the nexus between Arimdam
Das, Ajit Reddy, Bulu, Filio, Gautam Chatterjee and Matriprasad (the Sri
Aurobindo Ashram Trust's ...
This is Part IV of The Chronicles of the Inner
Chamber; readers of this series may first want to read the blog's
'Introduction' and the Matrimandir Action ...
Internal power struggle out in the open
Book controversy takes an ugly turn The Hindu PUDUCHERRY, February 28, 2012 UNREST: Devotees staging dharna outside the
Ashram Trust in Puducherry on Monday. Photo: T. Singaravelou A few Aurobindo
devotees stage dharna alleging that it has distorted the facts
The issue over the controversial book on Sri
Aurobindo took an ugly turn when a few of the devotees who were staging dharna
outside the Ashram Trust allegedly tried to “prevent” one of the seniormost
members of the Trust from entering the office and “snatch” files from his
possession. Police personnel posted near the dharna site prevented the two
groups from entering into a scuffle.
Police sources said they received a complaint from
Dilip Dutta, a senior member of the Trust, accusing the protesters of
physically trying to prevent him from entering the office and trying to snatch
files from his hand. He had also accused the group of verbally abusing him, a
police officer told The Hindu. However, a member of the protesting
group denied the accusation and said they were trying to hand over a petition to
Dr. Dutta.
A representative of the group that organised the
dharna told The Hindu that they had lodged a complaint with
Grand Bazaar police against Dr. Dutta and few others for indulging in “racial
abuse” and provoking the members. The controversy over the book, ‘The Lives of
Sri Aurobindo', written by American-born Ashram inmate Peter Heehs, has been
raging for a while now, particularly after the group opposed to the book
launched a series of protests in January demanding expulsion of Mr. Heehs and
resignation of members of Trust for not condemning the book openly. The group
launched a three-day protest on Sunday with a large number of them coming from
Odisha.
A release issued by the group said: “The book
contains objectionable matters depicting distorted facts about the life and
character of Sri Aurobindo. The Odisha government has declared that every copy
of the book, its copies, reprints, translations or other documents containing
the extracts taken be forfeited to the government.”
DECISION QUESTIONED
The group also questioned the Trust's decision to
stand as a guarantor to Mr. Heehs, who has sought a visa extension. The Trust had been maintaining that it would not do
any thing that “contravenes freedom of speech,” and any action on its part
against the book or author would be termed as “fundamentalist mindset”. A
senior member of the Trust said, “The considered view of the Trust is that it
does not project itself in the role of dictating to the readers and followers
of Sri Aurobindo as to what they should read and what they should not read.”
He added that “each person is at complete liberty to
decide for him whether he finds any book to be meaningful and useful or whether
he does not find it to be so. The Trust respects and has full faith in the
intellectual and spiritual discernment of the readers. No one should or need to
force his personal opinions on any other reader in general and more
particularly on the followers of Sri Aurobindo.”
There have been favourable reviews of the book by
large number of people, including eminent authors, he said pointing out that
any action against the author would invite the ire of those sections.
On the proscription of the book by the Orissa
government, he said it had been challenged in the High Court questioning the
validity of the order based on a few “extracts taken out of context from the
book.”
A senior inmate of the Ashram who objects to certain
portions of the book but at the same time who does not approve of the group
behind the protest said, “Mr. Heehs and his book is not the real issue but it
is the result of an internal power struggle going on for the last several
years.”
On issue of Mr. Heehs visa and his alleged
over-staying, a senior police officer said as of now he is an “unconfirmed
foreigner” who is allowed to stay till a final order of his visa application by
the Union Ministry of Home Affairs.
Spiritual Collectivities « Sri Aurobindo Studies Sri
Aurobindo raises the question in a whole chapter on “The Gnostic Being” in
the Life Divine, where he discusses how there has to be a gnostic society ...
Monday 27 February 2012
Ashramites on warpath
150 inmates of Aurobindo Ashram on three-day dharna
IBNLive.com 11:02 PM, Feb 26, 2012 Puducherry (PTI)
IBNLive.com 11:02 PM, Feb 26, 2012 Puducherry (PTI)
About 150 inmates of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram here
today embarked upon a three-day dharna demanding that trustees managing the
ashram be dismissed immediately for their "failure" to protect its
reputation. A release issued by a spokesman of the inmates and devotees of the
Ashram alleged that the Trustees had failed to take action against Peter Heehs,
a US national and inmate of the Ashram, for his controversial book titled ‘The
Lives of Sri Aurobindo’ published in 2008 in which the writer had allegedly
made "inflammatory and denigrating remarks" against Sri Aurobindo and
his spiritual collaborator, The Mother.
The present team of trustees should either resign or
be sacked as they are "protecting the writer without expelling him from
the Ashram although his controversial book had insulted and denigrated the
spiritual savants," it said. The inmates, staging the protest outside the
ashram premises, said in the release that the Trust should publicly condemn the
"insulting" book and withdraw the copyright permission to the
Columbia University Press which has published the book. The release said the
Union Home Ministry had "issued instructions" to various State
governments and Union
Territories to stop its
publication, sales and distribution. The Orissa government had through Gazette
notification in 2009 proscribed the book and declared its contents
`inflammatory in nature and ordered all copies of the book be forfeited`.
Meanwhile, a source in the Ashram Trust said
"according to many, who have written to the Ashram in appreciation of the
book, those who found the book to be offensive have either not read it in its
entirety or have clearly misunderstood its import." The source also said
the question whether the author of the book can stay in India or not
was entirely a matter "exclusively within the purview of the Union Home
Ministry." The Ashram was founded in 1926. Aurobindo passed away in 1950
while the Mother died in 1973. The Mother (Mira Alfassa) founded Aurobindo
International Centre of Education in 1952 and the international township of Auroville , 10 km from here, in 1968.
indiandefenceboard.com › Indian Strategic Affairs › Indian Politics
Netaji Subash Chandra Bose was the product of Bengal
Renaissance (1775 - 1941). The attempt to rationalize Hinduism by Sri
Aurobindo, Swami Vivekananda also espoused Atheism. The Germans also genuinely
attempted to rationalize Hinduism was used by British colony (through German
indologist Max Müller) and Christian missionaries to westernize Hinduism- which
continues till Today.
Netaji reflect this part of the Rationalism. Gandhi-Nehru
"shadowy non Violence" was part of "Tantra" like Kashmiri
Saivism, not of Hinduism- of course part of Hinduism - could not be understood
by ordinary people. This was evolved into Nehru's "Tryst with
Destny"- it is not in anyway Hindu "Sanatana Dharma" or fate or
Hegelian Dilectics- it was a rational? westernized interpretation of Hinduism.
India got Independence because of end of WWII and
British was no more in a position to maintain Colonies- in which Netaji and
INA's sacrifices was a strong catalyst than Gandhi - Nehru. Govinda, Jan 27, 2012 #51
Sunday 26 February 2012
We have never been open
Peter
Heehs’ The Lives of Sri Aurobindo by ned The Stumbling Mystic » Jul 20, 2008
I had no urge toward
spirituality in me, I developed spirituality. I was incapable of understanding
metaphysics, I developed into a philosopher. I had no eye for painting — I
developed it by Yoga. I transformed my nature from what it was to what it was not.
I did it by a special manner, not by a miracle and I did it to show what could
be done and how it could be done. I did not do it out of any personal necessity
of my own or by a miracle without any process. I say that if it is not so, then
my Yoga is useless and my life was a mistake — a mere absurd freak of Nature
without meaning or consequence. You all seem to think it a great
compliment to me to say that what I have done has no meaning for anybody except
myself — it is the most damaging criticism on my work that could be made. I
also did not do it by myself, if you mean by myself the Aurobindo that was. He
did it by the help of Krishna and the Divine
Shakti. I had help from human sources also. — Sri Aurobindo
Peter Heehs, a historian and student of Sri Aurobindo,
who works in the Archives section at the Sri Aurobindo Ashram in Pondicherry,
has published an excellent biography of Sri Aurobindo entitled The Lives of Sri Aurobindo. Published by the
Columbia University Press, this biography is written in a totally detached,
academic manner. In other words, it is not a hagiography, and people who are
not devotees of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother will also enjoy it.
The great strength of Peter’s book — which I’m
currently in the middle of — is that he mostly describes Sri Aurobindo’s human
personality for us. And what his book shows is that prior to Sri Aurobindo’s
major spiritual realizations, he was as human as any of us are. In other words,
all this hagiographic mythology that we often see surrounding Sri Aurobindo —
that he was born enlightened, or that he had no problems whatsoever during his
life or his yoga — is gratefully put to rest by Peter’s biography. Sri
Aurobindo’s life was full of harsh troubles, and it was by confronting them
that he managed to attain what he did. The fact that so many people seemed to think
that only Sri Aurobindo could have accomplished what he did must have been the
greatest source of frustration for him.
Some devotees of Sri Aurobindo might be put off by
Peter’s academic tone in this biography. After all, he never calls Sri
Aurobindo an “avatar” or anything like that in it. Indeed, Peter paints Sri
Aurobindo as humanly as he possibly can in this biography (which was partly
because he wanted a university publisher in order to reach a wider audience,
and partly because that’s his style — to be measured and detached). But
personally, I find that Peter’s writing style has increased my
faith in the integral yoga. And it is also helping me ground the yoga. Lest we
forget, this is an embodied yoga. What we are called to do, in
effect, is to perfect that embodiment, be more integrally embodied,
in short, to incarnate fully.
So, to sum up, what does all of this mean? It means
that even an idiot like myself, who started off as a lowly computer programmer,
can gradually teach herself to appreciate philosophy, poetry, painting and
metaphor by becoming more open to what Sri Aurobindo calls the “logic of the
Infinite”. By enduring and transcending pain, in my experience, we learn the
fine art of honing our perception and seeing things that we never saw before.
Through self-sacrifice we learn to receive gifts from the Divine Grace that we
can then put to the service of humanity.
It means there is hope for all of us. What a gift
Peter Heehs has given us.
Gender,
Traditionalism and Occultism by ned Jul 11, 2008
It’s been said that medieval mystics were more
intuitive and less rational than modern and postmodern humans are. This allowed
them easier access to higher realities, but it also meant that their mental or
rational formulations of those realities were often mythical. What I’m
suggesting is that a truly scientific occultism — and again I refer to Sri
Aurobindo’s Record of Yoga as having set the bar in this
area — will have to wait until we are ready for suprarational mysticism. I see
plenty of infrarational elements in medieval mysticism, which is why many
secular people reject it because it contains formulations that don’t make sense
in the light of modern-day findings.
Jung
and the Integral Yoga by ned Jul 13, 2008
I’m reading Jungian theory these days. I think Jung
got extremely close to the spiritual vision, though he never quite understood
that the ego has to be foregone completely. I believe Jung’s concept of
individuation is really a watered-down and distorted version of Sri Aurobindo’s
psychicisation. The psychic being is the highest individuality
— it is the most unique, most authentic expression of who each of us is — but
it is in harmony with the environment and every other individual.
Experiences
at the East-West Cultural Center by ned Jun 9, 2008
I also gave a short talk yesterday at the EWCC regarding
coming to Sri Aurobindo and the Mother from an Islamic background, and tossed
up some ideas for a reconciliation between Islam and Hinduism (I brought up
Ustadh Mahmoud Mohamed Taha’s somewhat heretical notion of the second message of Islam which
I mentioned in a previous post, as well as Ibn
al-Arabi and Rumi),
and between India and Pakistan (I brought up the Pakistani historian Hamza
Alavi’s excellent essay Pakistan and Islam: Ethnicity and Ideology, which I highly
recommend). I didn’t have time to bring up other things, which I wanted to,
such as Frithjof Schuon’s brilliant essay Mahashakti from his
book Roots of the Human Condition, which includes a
section on the role of the Shakti in Islam, as well as a book by M.
Rafique from Lahore comparing Allama Muhammad Iqbal (the architect of the idea of
Pakistan) and Sri Aurobindo (Iqbal, for all his errors, was actually
trying to synthesize evolution with Islam in a panentheistic cosmology,
inspired by Nietzsche, Bergson and Whitehead — there is certainly a dialogue to
be had here).
rereading Latour from Object-Oriented Philosophy by doctorzamalek
(Graham Harman) I don’t mean revising my interpretation, I mean that I’m
literally rereading We Have Never Been Modern, and enjoying it now
as ever. I always find new things on each rereading; it is extremely rich
despite being concise. This isn’t the usual view, I know, but it gets my vote
for the most important work of philosophy since the 1960′s, and one that hasn’t
been topped since its appearance in 1991.
To be perfectly blunt, I think it’s more important
than anything ever written by Derrida, Foucault, Deleuze, Badiou, etc. If you
haven’t read it, you could be costing yourself 10-15 years of needless spinning
of wheels on certain topics. Come out the other end of this book, and the
entire modern world looks different, as does the future in whatever lies beyond
the modern world. Ironically, Latour himself is no longer especially fond of
the book.
Thursday 23 February 2012
We do not need Makarand Paranjape, but need Gautam Chikermane
HT
HOME / BLOGS HOME > JUST
FAITH / RELIGION / Sri Aurobindo, Heehs and the fragility of faith: Just Faith
By Gautam Chikermane
And now, right under our noses, even as the national
discourse is moving against banning books and towards free speech, another
intellectual is being hounded. This time, it’s Peter Heehs, an American
historian, who has who has lived in and served the Sri Aurobindo Ashram for
41 years, set up the Ashram’s Archives department, has been the founding editor
of Sri Aurobindo: Archives and Research, and was part of the team that has
brought out the Complete Works of Sri Aurobindo. The ban in question is on
his scholarly biography of Sri Aurobindo titled, The Lives of Sri Aurobindo.
If Sri Aurobindo was still residing in his “cave” at
Pondicherry , he
would have welcomed the book, critiqued it — but most important, he would have
read it. But if an April 9, 2009 notification by the Orissa government is to be
taken seriously, this is what it suggests: we have not read the book but the
select excerpts given to us by interested parties is enough evidence for us to
ban the book. For those who enjoy legalese, you can read the notification here.
So far so good. During the course of my
investigation into this affair, this notification was given to me as “evidence”
by a party that’s fighting another case against the trustees of the Sri
Aurobindo Ashram, holding them responsible for harbouring Heehs and seeking
their removal. …
One last point on Heehs’s book. This time I invite
you to a sojourn in time, all of 30 years ago. In a November 8, 1982 judgement,
the Supreme Court declared that Sri Aurobindo’s teachings cannot be said to be
of a religious nature. “Numerous utterings by Sri Aurobindo or the Mother
unmistakably show that the Ashram or Society or Auroville is not a religious
institution,” the judgement said. “There can be no better proof than what Sri
Aurobindo and the Mother themselves thought of their teachings and their
institutions to find out whether the teachings of Sri Aurobindo and his
Integral Yoga constitute a religion or a
philosophy. The uttering made from time to time by Sri Aurobindo and the Mother
hardly leave any doubt about the nature of the institution. It was on the basis
that it was not a religious institution.” You can read another excerpt here.
The point: if Sri Aurobindo is not a religious
entity and his teachings not a religion, how can his biography hurt any
religious person? This is a question that many devotees, in their blind faith,
ignore. India is home to gurus and
spiritual teachers. All of them stated clearly that they are not professing a
religion but a way of life, call it spirituality if you must. To convert those
words, those ideas, those books, those teachings into a religion is the biggest
crime against their own gurus. If Sri Aurobindo were around, he would have
shuddered to have been called an author of yet another ‘religion’ and steered
clear of anything to do with it.
Those terming Sri Aurobindo’s yoga a religion need
to do their homework. If they are unwilling to go through the rigour of
reading, the least they should do is what Sri Aurobindo’s spiritual
collaborator The Mother suggested: “When you have nothing pleasant to say about
something or somebody in the Ashram, keep silent. You must know that this
silence is faithfulness to the Divine’s work.”
Aurotruths commented on New content: Attempts to create an "Aurobindonian
religion". in response to Tusar N. Mohapatra: [In time, a whole set of beliefs and rituals began
to be built up around Sri Aurobindo and more so, around The Mother. The death
of each of them caused dismay and disappointment among large sections of the
faithful. Many had grown to believe that some miraculous transformation of the
physical bodies of their Gurus [...]
Dear TNM, Thank you for your comment. However, we
would like to take this opportunity to inform you that we do not wish to
encourage re-blogging on this site as we prefer that this site should instead
have original content. Regarding Makarand Paranjape's opinion that "though
both Sri Aurobindo and The Mother repeatedly warned against the creation of a
cult around them, they themselves encouraged it in several ways. Sri Aurobindo
himself deified The Mother and vice versa..." it must be said
that just because Makarannd Paranjape thinks that They encouraged a cult, it
doesn't mean that it was so. Those who opine upon and judge Sri Aurobindo and
The Mother superficially are likely to derive conclusions that differ from
those clearly spelled out by Sri Aurobindo and The Mother Themselves. We
therefore do not need a Makarand Paranjape to tell us whether Sri Aurobindo and
The Mother contradicted themselves or not. For instance, The Mother in her own
words said (Words of the Mother-I, 2004 ed., p. 110): "Here we do not have
religion. We replace religion by the spiritual life, which is truer, deeper and
higher at the same time, that is to say, closer to the Divine. For the Divine
is in everything, but we are not conscious of it. This is the immense progress
that man must make." But we can understand that for those who cannot
distinguish the difference between Spirituality and Religion, Sri Aurobindo's
and The Mother's words and actions might be confusing. But if such people are
really interested in understanding Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, isn't it their
responsibility to make the effort to raise their level of understanding and
come closer to what They clearly stated, rather than to drag Them down to one's
own level of understanding? Editors, Auro Truths.
The Only Cure for Cynicism is More Cynicism from One Cʘsmos by Gagdad
Bob
Perhaps an autobiographical example will help. Not
mine, but Sri Aurobindo's (and I raise his example not to promulgate Vedanta,
but first because it comes readily to mind, second because I believe that what
he describes is universal, a kind of stage we must all pass through on the
journey back to God).
Whatever else he was, little Auro was clearly a
brilliant lad, educated at Cambridge ,
fluent in several languages, recipient of various academic prizes. But when he
later turned to spiritual development, he came to a point that he saw through
this game -- and it is a game -- first from a lateral, and then vertical,
perspective. In a letter, he wrote that
"The capital period of my intellectual
development was when I could see clearly that what the intellect said might be
correct and not correct, that what the intellect justified was true and its
opposite also was true. I never admitted a truth in the mind without
simultaneously keeping it open to the contrary of it.... And the first
result was that the prestige of the intellect was gone."
Now that I think about it, I had this experience
quite vividly around the time I was working on my master's degree, during the
last period of my life that I smoked marijuana. On the one hand, I was learning
all this academic stuff which all the experts agreed one must know in order to
call oneself a "psychologist."
Wednesday 22 February 2012
Nothing is ever to be considered inanimate
from: Atala Damodar damodar.atala@gmail.com date: 22 February 2012 16:45 subject: Reg. 'Lives'
the letter to Vijay Bhai from 'students'
1. 'INANIMATE'
If We read Mother and Sri Aurobindo carefully,
nothing is ever to be considered inanimate! Especially a book is the body and mind of the author who writes it. It's not on interpretations or our understanding that a book's objectivity has to be judged. A compilation of anecdotes or presentation of facts without personal, mental(='intellectual/scholarly') comments and arranging them without personal choices and neither suppressing any fact nor highlighting any details; all these without any personal bias may satisfy the terms of objectivity. But 'Lives of Sri Aurobindo' has personal explanation, 'intellectual(?)analysis', biased omissions, preferred highlights...!
2. As to "We believe that except for Sri Aurobindo, none of us will know who is right and who is wrong and that this matter should be left to him alone, especially in the absence of a clear-cut consensus.": What an absurd logic! A consensus can never be an indicator, evidence, or proof of veracity! Just like in democracy an elected or non contested candidate is not the people's real representative.
Had it been written by Sri Aurobindo, it could have been left to 'Him' alone. In this case if any one takes the position of 'leaving to him alone' to belittle, mar, distort, denigrate Sri Aurobindo and His words; then logically he should also leave others (including Vijay Bhai, Shradhalu, Niranjan, R Y Deshpande et al) to expose his work and put their genuine feelings and 'Intellectual/scholarly analyses' on record.
So Freedom of Speech for ALL or for only those so called western scholars who DO NOT BELIEVE in Sri Aurobindo as an Avatar but take him as a mere 'psycho' individual with not only split personality but multiple 'Lives' to be dissected with freudian /Jungian psycho analytical scalpel under 'western mindset-microscope'?
2. As to "We believe that except for Sri Aurobindo, none of us will know who is right and who is wrong and that this matter should be left to him alone, especially in the absence of a clear-cut consensus.": What an absurd logic! A consensus can never be an indicator, evidence, or proof of veracity! Just like in democracy an elected or non contested candidate is not the people's real representative.
Had it been written by Sri Aurobindo, it could have been left to 'Him' alone. In this case if any one takes the position of 'leaving to him alone' to belittle, mar, distort, denigrate Sri Aurobindo and His words; then logically he should also leave others (including Vijay Bhai, Shradhalu, Niranjan, R Y Deshpande et al) to expose his work and put their genuine feelings and 'Intellectual/scholarly analyses' on record.
So Freedom of Speech for ALL or for only those so called western scholars who DO NOT BELIEVE in Sri Aurobindo as an Avatar but take him as a mere 'psycho' individual with not only split personality but multiple 'Lives' to be dissected with freudian /Jungian psycho analytical scalpel under 'western mindset-microscope'?
from: Jitendra Sharma aurofrance@gmail.com date: 22 February 2012 21:15 subject: Comment on
"Nothing is ever to be considered inanimate"
A book is a printed or written literary work,
consisting of words. Sri Aurobindo says:
“The Word has power - even the ordinary written word has a power. If it is an inspired word it has still more power. What kind of power or power for what depends on the nature of the inspiration and the theme and the part of the being it touches. If it is the Word itself, - as in certain utterances of the great Scriptures, Veda, Upanishads, Gita, it may well have a power to awaken a spiritual uplifting impulse, even certain kinds of realization.”
“The Word has power - even the ordinary written word has a power. If it is an inspired word it has still more power. What kind of power or power for what depends on the nature of the inspiration and the theme and the part of the being it touches. If it is the Word itself, - as in certain utterances of the great Scriptures, Veda, Upanishads, Gita, it may well have a power to awaken a spiritual uplifting impulse, even certain kinds of realization.”
“a
book is an inanimate object”. (Whoever wrote this should be given the Nobel
prize for literature and science combined.) The
Nexus Between Some Ex-Students and Matriprasad
BEYOND LOKPAL: TOWARDS A LASTING REMEDY FOR CORRUPTION Messages in this topic [sbicitizen] M.S. SRINIVASAN
The debate on Lokpal seemed to have died down and its implementation is at a
stalemate. However it provides an opportunity to revive and raise the debate at
a higher level, beyond Lokpal. Outer remedies for corruption like LokPal are
necessary but not enough.
The lasting remedy to corruption lies in eliminating or transforming the
corrupting element in us and strengthening our purer and nobler self which is
the source of virtues, values and character. Without this inner transformation,
if we keep the corrupting darkness within us unchanged and untouched, it will
seep through every human institution, including those created to eliminate
corruption. So the long-term remedy to corruption lies not in creating more and
more external institution for policing corruption, but in building inner
character in people and in our leaders. In other words, what we need today is a
character building education.
But what do we mean by "character." or to be more precise, a good,
noble or integral character? Popular conceptions associate characters with
outward nobility in behaviour like for example, freedom from smoking, drinking
or sexual indulgence. But the foundation of character is inward. A well-known
modern seer once told bluntly a conservative audience something like this: most
of you sitting here are full of negative thoughts and feelings like envy,
jealousy, greed but outwardly presenting a socially respectable appearance. But
when someone indulges in sex you look down upon him as immoral. With all the
immoral feelings within you, in what way you are better? There is a valid truth
in this observation. This doesn't mean right outer behaviour or action is not
important. But our outer behaviour will be authentic, sincere and effective
only when it is a spontaneous expression of a corresponding inner condition.
So, building character has to be a process which has to begin from within, by
sowing seeds of character in the consciousness of the individual. What are
these seeds of character? Clarity and sincerity in the mind; kindness,
generosity and compassion in the heart; strength, firmness and self-mastery in
the will; courage, energy and endurance in the vitality; aspiration for higher
values like truth, beauty and goodness in the soul and the will to manifest
them in the outer life: these are the qualities which constitute what
we call as "strength of character". In a spiritual perspective,
freedom from ego, desire and selfishness in thought, feelings, will and action
are the foundation of character.
How to build such a balanced character? Not by moral sermons and lectures but
by an inner and outer discipline put into practice in our daily life, with a
sustained persistence. (1) (M.S. Srinivasan is a Research Associate at Sri Aurobindo Society, Puducherry , India .
Email: srinivasan@aurosociety.org)
Notes: (1) For a more detailed discussion on this discipline and the subject as
a whole, reader may see the February issue of the e-magazine in management: The
Fourth Dimension Inc: http://fdi.sriaurobindosociety.org.in/cms/index.php
I suppose the lesson has always stayed with me. It
accounts for my cynicism over the Lok Pal and the concept of “Persons of
unimpeachable integrity”… In general, I am sceptical of any solution that
relies on people’s character rather than structures and incentives. 10:39 AM
Tuesday 21 February 2012
The Mother’s work is not a chimera, nor a utopia
The following is the introductory text to the exhibition
of photographs I took in 1983: “Sadhaks of Integral Yoga – Sri Aurobindo Ashram”,
displayed at Pitanga, Auroville, February 14 – March 3, 2012. Monday to
Saturday 8-12.30 and 2 – 6 pm. Closed on Sundays, and on 28th February.
SADHAKS
AT THE SRI AUROBINDO ASHRAM, ‘PARADISE ON
EARTH’
December
1973, Sri Aurobindo Ashram. I address in French a young Indian woman standing
at the gate. She replies in French and takes me to the inner courtyard, the
location of the ‘samadhi’, a white marble memorial where Sri Aurobindo’s and
Mother’s bodies are laid to rest. Upon seeing the sacred shrine covered with
flowers, along with all the people clad in white, who appear to me like angels,
tears roll down my cheeks. I feel that I have returned home, finding the way
back to realms I had visited as a child, and then lost. Vainly had I tried to
pierce through the veil to that world again; but the more I tried, the more it
kept eluding me, like a distant dream.
The
following day the young woman – who happens to be the granddaughter of the late
Rishabchand[1] – takes me to her
home, where she lived with her younger sister and her aunt. At the age of three
she was presented to the Mother and, unable to separate from her, she refused
to return to her prosperous family in Calcutta .
So the Mother confided the child to her aunt, a yogini who spent eight hours a
day for twenty-eight years, until 1962, in the Mother’s room at Her service.
During those years there was, as yet, no kindergarten at the Ashram; so,
following her auntie about, Mounnou also spent her days in the Mother’s room.
The young woman who, as a child, sat on Champaklal’s lap, while playing with
his beard, became my first friend there – and her aunt, one of the Mother’s
attendant, my second. I was subsequently introduced to the world of the early
sadhaks of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram, paraphrasing the words of Nolinida[2], “paradise on earth”.
These
relationships were my gateway to that other world, the Sri Aurobindo
Ashram of the golden years, which was under the direct guidance of Sri
Aurobindo and the Mother, who were charting the path to the Supermind and
a unitary world of free multiplicity. But let’s never forget that
at the same time Nirod, the prankster, graciously entertained Sri Aurobindo on
a variety of subjects and, with both of them cracking jokes, everything turned
into laughter. The Divine is humour too; it is an important aspect of Grace.
There are no words to describe the way I felt, as I was privy to secret
teachings not through words, but by example and radiance of being, which I
received from each and all of them. I never felt lonely or abandoned as, for
me, the Guru was there, in them, through them, immortal.
Guru,
father, mother, spouse, child and revolutionary companion, Sri Aurobindo was
everything for me, the beginning and end of my universe. I pursued my path my
own way, spontaneously, shunning those giving advices and ludicrously posing as
teachers: the Guru is within, in the sanctuary of one’s heart, and there is no
other teaching. I was forced to build a barrier to prevent the intrusion of
blabbering parrot-like people with their endless chant, “Mother told me this,
Mother told me that.” The consequence of the inner violence perpetrated by such
individuals was that, for the first one and half years, I could not open to the
Mother. I recognized two opposite worlds: that of the early sadhaks, for whom
everything was divine, and their atmosphere in which I bathed, where only Love
exists, and Love and more Love, the world of pure psychic beings – and that of
the others’, a lifeless, dull parody of what cannot be taught. Nor did the
sadhaks take offence when told that I was unable to accept the Mother because
of the others’ idle chatter. My bond with Sri Aurobindo was such that the
Mother’s attendant, her family and others in their special milieu kept on
laughing, while telling me, “One day you will remember her.” And when that day
actually came, I fell on my knees. But I
will never forget the loving compassion and liberalism of those early sadhaks,
who accepted me as I was: a young married Italian woman, but who came alone, as
yet without a clue on the nature and significance of the Avatar and, on top of
that, even refusing the Mother! They simply kept on cheerfully laughing at my
foolish resistance and that was it.
With
the special permission of the Ashram Trust I was allowed to live for a few
months with J. K. K., the Mother’s attendant, in the house allotted to her. The
Mother had come there three times and sat on her bed, to stop the young woman
with a fiery character from leaving the Ashram. Two younger sadhikas shared my
friend’s house with her; in the past, up to six female ashramites had been
living there, sharing the kitchen and common exterior bathroom. Experiencing
the life of early ashramites from close up gave me a hint of how their sadhana
proceeded, in a path that makes no distinction between the inner and outer
life, both being mutually interdependent. In Their yoga, perfection through
purnayoga is to be attained in one’s daily work and living, at every
instant, as a perpetual offering to the Divine of one’s thoughts, feelings and
deeds. When J. K. K. came in the thirties she was only eighteen, and the Mother
almost immediately chose her as one of her attendants. The way she had
come was special too. The Ashram, then, had only a hundred and twenty
inmates, living in basic facilities and having no contacts with the external
world, and there were no new admissions. Consequently, few people were
appointed to deal with eventual visitors. The Mother dealt with each case
individually, with her assignments and accommodations differing according to
the inner needs and development of the disciple. The Ashram had so little money,
those days, that tea was served only once a day; once a week the ashramites
cued like little children to get a mint candy that the Mother put in their
mouth.
Day
in and day out, year in and year out, mostly at teatime, J. K. K. told me
precious details about the Mother and her surroundings. Though afterwards her
family lost its wealth, the Mother had been brought up a distinguished lady
with a superior education. Both intellectually and artistically she was at
the cultural summit of being. Yet, my friend informed me how careful the Mother
was with the humblest things, which moved me to tears. The lingerie the
Mother wore under her exquisite external vestments, given to her by loving
disciples, was carefully mended when necessary. She did not discard one single
object; even ordinary boxes and scraps of paper were reused. My sadhika friend
dealt in the same way with her own clothes and objects, treating them as old
friends. For decades after the Mother left the body, J. K. K.’s sadhana
continued to involve wiping every object down to the tiniest in the Mother’s
old room, which is adjacent to Sri Aurobindo’s.[3]
I
started extensively reading Sri Aurobindo’s and the Mother’s books, publishing
long compilations in book-form from their works, only when I moved to
Auroville. Bathing in the atmosphere of the early sadhaks, as long as I
lived in Pondicherry
the Mother’s Prayers and Meditations and
Sri Aurobindo’s Last Poems were all I
longed for. My sadhana proceeded according to my experience, as a humble initiate,
of the spiritual significance the Mother had given to flowers, which she saw as
a powerful tool to trigger the emergence of the psychic being. Inwardly
integrating the message of some of the flowers, artistically displayed in the
shape of a mandala on the samadhi, I got the message for the day. The first
year I did not even ride a bicycle, I only walked, as every flower or blade of
grass, every spot on the walls or sidewalks was a source of wonder and delight.
By repeating the same act every day, at the same time, in the presence of the
same people, I gradually understood what the path of Integral Yoga is all
about: day-to-day methodical routine fully concentrated on the Divine. The sadhaka is alone with the Divine, with no other guru but one’s
psychic being. Meditation or other practices, even states of samadhi, are no
more than optional, the way of Integral Yoga being relentless concentration, at
every instant of time. Whether awake and engrossed in work and one’s daily
activities or sleeping and dreaming, a state of inward concentration is
required, encompassing all layers and planes of being from the subtlest to the
densest, down to the last cell in the body.
This
is what I learnt, without words, just absorbing like a sponge the atmosphere
radiating from those sadhakas. Some had come very young; others got married and
had children but, by the time they joined the Sri Aurobindo Ashram, they were
there for the Divine and only the Divine. Through their integrity and total
dedication, their utmost simplicity that is true greatness of being I felt,
tangibly, that the Mother’s work is not a chimera, nor a utopia. I
realized that it is the future awaiting all of us the moment we surrender to
the Call. Ultimately, it is the only thing worth living for, the very purpose
of our taking birth, our mission and our destiny.
That
world, Nolinida’s ‘paradise on earth’, and my own too, because of which I left
behind whatever I had, is no more. I had the privilege to be a witness of it
for a while, as long as it was able to manifest, before having to plunge back
to our day-to-day reality, with all its harshness but also its challenges and
call for transformation. Whenever it becomes too tough and I feel I can no
longer take it I take shelter in that world, which is eternal and exists
forever; calling for the Mother’s Grace that we too, in Auroville as at the Sri
Aurobindo Ashram, can become living messengers of beauty and graciousness, with
the pure flow of psychic and divine love. Paulette paulette@auroville.org.in
[1] A man of
considerable intellect and a sadhak who lived at the Sri
Aurobindo Ashram, Rishabhchand is the author of the first ‘political’ biography
of Sri Aurobindo, written on the Mother’s request, and of a compendium on
Integral Yoga, also written on her request, to introduce the Path to the West. Several
members of his family became members of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram a
long time ago. J. K. K. was his sister-in-law.
[2] Sri
Aurobindo considered Nolini Kanta Gupta his most advanced disciple, and the one
who had the best understanding of his Yoga. Freedom fighter Nolini was closely
associate to the Master since their nationalist years.
[3] The
Mother lived there until 1962, prior to the attack by the false “Sri Aurobindo”
that nearly cost her life.
Monday 20 February 2012
Inmates and devotees of Sri Aurobindo Ashram demand Dismissal of the present group of Trustees
[The following application to the Pondicherry administration for the silent
protest of January 1-6, 2012 was made by a few inmates of the Sri Aurobindo
Ashram. Six of these inmates received show-cause notices from the Trustees.
Why? Because they were bold enough to sit for a silent and peaceful protest
against the inaction of the Trustees with regard to Peter Heehs. So what makes
the Trust inactive in one case and super-active in another? That is a million
dollar question! In any case, this application, which has a very good summary
of events that have led to the present crisis, was attached to the show-cause
notices of those inmates who signed it.]
Since the Trust Deed does not define the method of
selection of the Trustees nor the method of their removal, the present Trustees
have taken full advantage of this lacuna and have formed a self-selected
coterie of vested interests who are freely and openly misusing their
position… As a result the Ashram community has
found its interests hijacked by a small coterie of people who want to harm Sri
Aurobindo’s name and his Work. (It is pertinent to note that none of
the present trustees of the Ashram Trust were nominated by the Mother.) Senior
members of the Ashram community, who have worked closely with the Mother, felt
that they had to take suitable action to defend the reputation of Sri
Aurobindo and to protect the long-term interests of the Ashram community for
which the Mother created the Trust. The senior members held several rounds of
discussions with representatives of various groups of devotees and the members
of the Ashram community sharing their pain and deep distress. Many
attempts were made by them and by various independent groups to resolve the
problem internally by dialogue, mediation, discussion, pleas, etc, with the
Trustees. All these attempts failed as the Trustees declared that they were
answerable to nobody in the Ashram, and refused to explain or justify their
misuse of Ashram funds and the Ashram’s name to harm Sri Aurobindo. All these
attempts have failed and the Trust Board has instead launched a widespread
campaign of intimidation and rule by fear and threat…
Application
and Demand of the Inmates and Devotees of Sri Aurobindo Ashram
In
view of the above and having exhausted all means and measures of an internal
amicable and peaceful settlement, the inmates of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram and
devotes of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother seek the permission and sanction of the
Police and local authorities concerned to press for their legal grievances and
demands, namely:
1. Dismissal
of the present group of Trustees of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust.
2. Unconditional
reinstatement of all who have been victimised by denial of food, work, and
other facilities of the Ashram community life.
3. Cessation
and withdrawal of all threats and coercive measures initiated against the
inmates and residents of the Ashram community and devotees.
4. Immediate
expulsion of Peter Heehs from the Ashram community.
5. Recovery
of all documents belonging to the Ashram which are still kept in the exclusive
possession of Peter Heehs.
6. Public
declaration by the Trust that the book The Lives of Sri Aurobindo authored
by Peter Heehs is factually incorrect and does not represent the views of the
Ashram community and the Ashram Trust and that Peter Heehs has abused his
position at the Archives and indulged in criminal impersonation as the Founder
of the Ashram’s Archives Department.
7. Withdrawal
of copyright permission to Columbia University Press which has published the
offending book without suitable copyright permissions.
8. Public
apology by the present members of the Board of Trustees for having promoted
abuse and insult of Sri Aurobindo’s name, and for causing so much pain and
distress to the inmates and residents of the Ashram community and to all
devotees at large.
Sunday 19 February 2012
The Lives of Sri Aurobindo has sparked a bitter controversy
Extracts from Reviews of The
Lives of Sri Aurobindo Click here to
go to full reviews
Most books on Sri Aurobindo are hagiographical, with
little or no biographical information; in keen contrast, this book covers in
great detail the various stages of his life. - Ramakrishna Puligandla in Choice more>>
The overall result is a masterful and inspiring
biography that provides a solid foundation for further Aurobindo studies and
offers plenty of cues for other kinds of historical, textual, and exegetical
work that could enhance our understanding of the multiple sites in which
Aurobindo lived and worked. - Hanna H. Kim in H-Net Reviews more >>
This meticulously reported and scrupulously
footnoted account of the Bengali saint Sri Aurobindo leaves no stone unturned. -
Nora Isaacs in Yoga Journal more>>
Peter Heehs has done a great deal of research
lasting many years, working in archives in Delhi ,
Calcutta , Baroda ,
London , and Paris . - Christine Devin in Revue
d’Auroville more>>
Not only is the book remarkably well researched but,
as the title indicates, he has really covered all aspects of Sri Aurobindo’s
life. - François Gautier in The New Indian Express more>>
The author has given us a model biography, which is
accessible to the general public. - David Annoussamy in Le
Trait-d'union more>>
In this essay I will steer clear of the controversy
as far as possible, examining the book in the wider context of Heehs’s other
writings, most of which are aimed primarily at academic audiences. part 1>> part 2>> - Marcel Kvassay in AntiMatters
If you read only one book about Aurobindo, again,
this volume would get my vote. It stands in a class all its own. There is
simply no other book about Aurobindo available that does all that Heehs’s book
does. - W. Michael Ashcraft in Nova Religio more>>
It is not as if he has set out to demythologise
Aurobindo but he does seek to write a life as firmly based on evidence as he
can. . . . Heehs has endeavoured to produce an objective account of Aurobindo
and it is a formidable piece of scholarship. - Antony Copley in Journal
of the Royal Asiatic Society more>>
While biographies of Aurobindo have been published
before, including a short one by Heehs himself, none has ever drawn on such a
vast resource of original letters, diaries, and other primary sources. -
Ellen Daly in EnlightenNext more>>
Despite his massive political and spiritual
influence, the twentieth century Indian revolutionary turned mystic Sri
Aurobindo Ghose has been curiously neglected in Western scholarship. - Ann
Gleig in Religious Studies Review more>>
With this book, Peter Heehs has done the job of
examining Aurobindo in his entirety with remarkable success, and has aptly
titled his work The Lives of Sri Aurobindo. - Jayant Bapat in South
Asia more>>
Peter Heehs makes a commendable effort at rescuing a
leading thinker of modern times from uncharitable critics.... Personally
speaking, I have not found a more lucid description of complex constructs like
the 'supermind'. - Amiya P. Sen in The Book Review more>>
In
this book, he has made defamatory and perverse comments on Sri Aurobindo’s
character, life, writings and thought. Among other things, he seeks to show
that:
1. Sri
Aurobindo does not hold integrity as a person,
2. He
was morally of loose character,
3. His
claims to spiritual experiences and realisations are questionable and
irrelevant,
4. His
spirituality emerges from a streak of inherited madness,
5. There
is nothing new in any of his contributions, spiritual, literary, philosophical
or otherwise,
6. That
he was responsible for the partition of India ,
7. His
poetry is expressive of sexual frustration, and its style outdated, and
8. His
relationship with the Mother was romantic in nature.
An
analysis of the book reveals that the defamatory statements are deliberately
intended by the simple fact that in order to support such perverse statements,
Peter, the author of this book, deceives the reader by false and cooked-up
quotation, misquotations, quoting out of context, and deliberately concealing
facts to the contrary. It is very clear that the book is written for the sake
of defaming Sri Aurobindo and is intended to hurt the sentiments of the Indian
people and of admirers of Sri Aurobindo.
The
kinds of deceptions consistently utilised throughout the book include:
a) Deliberately
concealing the much larger body of information contrary to his defamatory
thesis;
b) Presenting
as quotations what are Peter Heehs’ imaginations and speculations;
c) Deliberate
misrepresentation and distortion of context;
d) Defaming
Sri Aurobindo’s character by use of innuendo, speculation, exaggeration and
outright falsehood;
e) Bias
to quote extensively from people who question Sri Aurobindo’s credibility and
sanity; outright rejection of any person or quotation offering appreciation or
praise of Sri Aurobindo;
f) Preferring
speculation against Sri Aurobindo’s own affirmations to the contrary;
g) Academically
unsound and perverse attempts at Freudian analysis of Sri Aurobindo’s
personality;
h) Perverse
speculations on the sexual and marital life of Sri Aurobindo.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
